docs: replace vague provenance prose with recorded facts

2026-08-09 15:35:02 +08:00
parent 8c124f84b6
commit 9704749b01
380 changed files with 946 additions and 874 deletions
@@ -2,5 +2,5 @@
 # side as of the last confirmed-consistent state. Both languages carry equal authority;
 # after editing either side, bring the other along and re-record with:
 #   pnpm run verify-translation-pairing --write docs/cookbook/maintaining-dsh-code-review.md
-maintaining-dsh-code-review.md: 2b5d0d926ae922f2650daac33cf35991cb71c5e5
-maintaining-dsh-code-review.zh.md: 4466565b294ede89fa34da9e76b88f4ac39748eb
+maintaining-dsh-code-review.md: 8aa8a5792bff2c49041f2f8b5e8146e7cff14e0e
+maintaining-dsh-code-review.zh.md: b26c98e8679eece78e72ee684580c1ed1181aa7c
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ Run the private tool daily with a two-UTC-day overlap; until the proposed schedu

 1. It selects PRs merged in the chosen window (default two UTC days for the daily cadence, seven for weekly) whose merge commit is reachable from `origin/master`. PRs whose merge commit is not reachable (stacked branches whose parent was squashed) or that exceed a 250-commit acquisition cap are logged to `skipped-pulls.json` and skipped rather than aborting the run.
 2. It collects pre-merge human review feedback with commit anchors (inline comments and review submissions), then compares feedback-time and final landed PR patches. It does not acquire PR conversation comments because current GitHub state cannot give them a force-push-safe feedback-time baseline, and it excludes target-branch-only changes from adoption evidence.
-3. Two independently configured reviewer adapters classify provenance and adoption, then classify agreed-adopted items against the current skill.
+3. Two independently configured reviewer adapters classify who wrote each item and whether the change adopted it, then classify agreed-adopted items against the current skill.
 4. The primary adapter drafts a complete revised `SKILL.md`; both adapters review the same diff; blocking findings loop until both approve.
 5. `pnpm run doc-sync` and `pnpm run lint` run against the candidate before the tool declares success.

@@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ When a run produces a candidate, a macOS notification arrives with a `dsh-code-r
     rm ~/dsh-code-review-outputs/2026-07-16T02-00-00Z.{diff,SKILL.md,manifest.json}
     ```
   - **Batch.** Keep the candidate aside if the update is small and could combine with a future one. The source-skill check still applies; rerun the analysis or manually rebase and re-review the diff if `master` changes first.
-   - **Promote.** From a clean `master` checkout of the repo, run the promote helper. It refreshes `master`, verifies that the current skill matches the recorded source blob, applies the saved diff, and opens a draft PR whose body carries the manifest's provenance summary. It stops on skill drift rather than overwriting newer guidance; the operator still reviews the PR on GitHub and either merges it or closes it.
+   - **Promote.** From a clean `master` checkout of the repo, run the promote helper. It refreshes `master`, verifies that the current skill matches the recorded source blob, applies the saved diff, and opens a draft PR whose body lists the source feedback URLs or IDs, landed commit range, originating run, checks, and operator edits. It stops on skill drift rather than overwriting newer guidance; the operator still reviews the PR on GitHub and either merges it or closes it.

     ```sh
     cd ~/path/to/deepseek-harness   # clean master
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@

 1. 选择指定窗口内合并、且合并 commit 可从 `origin/master` 到达的 PR（每天运行默认选择 2 个 UTC 日，每周运行选择 7 日）。合并 commit 无法到达的 PR（例如父分支被 squash 的堆叠分支），或超出 250 个 commit 获取上限的 PR，会记录到 `skipped-pulls.json` 并跳过，不会中止本次运行。
 2. 收集合并前带 commit 锚点的人工评审反馈（行内评论和评审提交），然后比较反馈时与最终落地的 PR patch。它不获取 PR 会话评论，因为 GitHub 当前状态无法为这些评论提供可抵抗 force-push 的反馈时基线；它也不会把只存在于目标分支的变更作为采纳证据。
-3. 两个独立配置的评审适配器先对来源和采纳情况分类，再根据当前 skill 对双方一致认定已采纳的条目分类。
+3. 两个独立配置的评审适配器先对每个条目的作者以及更改是否采纳了它进行分类，再根据当前 skill 对双方一致认定已采纳的条目分类。
 4. 主适配器起草完整修订版 `SKILL.md`；两个适配器评审同一份 diff；只要仍有阻塞性问题，循环就会继续，直到双方批准。
 5. 工具声明成功前，会针对候选版本运行 `pnpm run doc-sync` 和 `pnpm run lint`。

@@ -38,7 +38,7 @@
     rm ~/dsh-code-review-outputs/2026-07-16T02-00-00Z.{diff,SKILL.md,manifest.json}
     ```
   - **留待成批处理。** 如果更新很小，可以把候选版本留待与后续版本合并。源 skill 检查仍然适用；如果 `master` 先发生变化，请重新运行分析，或手动 rebase 并重新评审 diff。
-   - **提升。** 在仓库的干净 `master` checkout 中运行提升辅助工具。它会刷新 `master`、验证当前 skill 与记录的源 blob 一致、应用保存的 diff，并创建一份 draft PR，其正文包含 manifest 的来源摘要。如果 skill 已发生漂移，它会停止而不是覆盖更新后的指导；操作员仍需在 GitHub 上评审 PR，并选择合并或关闭。
+   - **提升。** 在仓库的干净 `master` checkout 中运行提升辅助工具。它会刷新 `master`、验证当前 skill 与记录的源 blob 一致、应用保存的 diff，并创建一份 draft PR，其正文列出原始反馈的 URL 或 ID、已落地的 commit 范围、发起这次更改的运行、检查以及操作员编辑。如果 skill 已发生漂移，它会停止而不是覆盖更新后的指导；操作员仍需在 GitHub 上评审 PR，并选择合并或关闭。

     ```sh
     cd ~/path/to/deepseek-harness   # clean master