Responding to review on #661: a public method on the generic ToolRegistry
service whose only caller is the run_code bridge was ad-hoc surface
widening. The bridge now receives it as a registry-private capability
closure in RunCodeBridgeOptions (the requireRuntime idiom, alongside the
cap), the method is private, and it leaves the generated service
catalog/API surfaces.
The pattern is now named as a code smell where reviewers look: the
packages/AGENTS.md capability-interface rule gains the inverse-smell
clause (ceiling 660→675 — the list is at capacity and the clause needs
one sentence), and dsh-code-review's capability-fit check tells reviewers
to flag single-consumer public service methods and require the closure
form.
Responding to ds-review-bot round 2 on #661:
- logWork is bounded: past maxParallelSubCalls pending shaped-append tasks
the ordered commit lane holds (Promise.race drains one), so a slow spill
backend backpressures the run instead of accumulating unbounded pending
I/O and retained results. Tasks self-remove on settlement; run
settlement still drains every task inside the open turn. New spill test
drives three oversized reads against a hung backend at cap 1 and proves
the third dispatch cannot start until a save drains.
- shapeDispatchLog's catch uses errorMessage() (total), so a thrown value
with a throwing toString cannot escape the containment and lose the
settle event.
- CodeDispatchLog.content documented as the RENDERED result projection
(native tool/result vocabulary), not what the program received — the
program gets the structured value; doc pair + type-equiv re-synced.
- New RECORDED tui-agent snapshot scenario code-mode-dispatch-spill: the
real Loader-visible composition (worker runtime + spill-local + policy)
drives an oversized bash sub-call end-to-end; replay proves the durable
dispatch copy is bounded to preview + locator while the program value
stays whole (the outer result carries just the line count).
Agent Note updated (both languages).
Conflict resolution: drainDispatches composes both sides — the reworked
single-lane driver's drive() (ordered stages, mid-flight commit drain)
followed by this branch's logWork drain, so every shaped settle append
still lands inside the open run_code turn.
Responding to ds-review-bot round 2 on #658 (three critical findings, one
warning — all rooted in the pump/commit split racing ordered stages):
- ONE driver lane now owns every ordered stage: the start append, prepare
(pre-execute/guards), and the head-of-line commit (post-execute, context
deferral, settle append). start() is awaited before the next entry can
start, so concurrent submissions can no longer run pre-execute pipelines
concurrently; only the around-dispatch/body stage overlaps, matching the
native loop's fillPool sequencing.
- An exclusive call's barrier now holds through its COMMIT: later starts
wait for the exclusive pipeline (post-execute included) to finish, the
native exclusive-group semantics.
- drainDispatches() awaits the driver run itself, so a commit already
mid-flight when the program returns is drained before run_code closes
the turn — the settle event and deferred contexts land inside it.
- maxParallelSubCalls is resolved and validated at construction (positive
integer), so direct construction can no longer wedge the pool with 0.
New tests: overlapping-submission ordered-prepare, barrier-through-commit,
drain-mid-commit, cap rejection. 96 keyless snapshots replay unchanged;
Agent Note updated (both languages).
The coverage gate flagged three untaken paths in the bridge scheduler:
- the exclusive-head inFlight re-check was dead (the shared guard above
already returns for an exclusive head with any in-flight sibling) — removed;
- the commit-cursor undefined-dispatched break was structurally unreachable
once entries join commitQueue only after start() ran synchronously —
reordered the pump so the invariant holds by construction, annotated;
- the finish (final-result) commit arm and the pump re-entry guard gain a
covering test (throwing tools/pre-execute listener) and a defensive
annotation respectively; mid-run unregistration test renamed to match its
actual post-result settlement path.
Also covers the direct-construction maxParallelSubCalls default (index.ts)
and commits the regenerated persistence catalog for the new dispatch pair.
ds-review-bot findings on the parallel bridge: sub-dispatches now run
through the registry's staged scheduler view (the loop's own seam) —
ordered prepare (pre-execute/guards) at submission-ordered start time,
only the dispatch/body stage overlapping, and a head-of-line commit
cursor running post-execute, context deferral, and the settle event in
submission order (new spec pins post order + context order under
out-of-order completion). Queued dispatches reclassify via
executionMode() immediately before starting, so a registry mutation
while queued flips them exclusive (native lazy-reclassification
semantics). Config and tool catalogs regenerated; the tool-catalog
metadata now names the start/settle pair and the scheduling contract.
ds-review-bot findings: the packaged Python runtime smoke's scripted
run_code call gains the required description; the ToolDefinition JSDoc
and the Code Mode foundation note (both languages, pair re-recorded) now
state both required parameters; the cordis-dynamic-toolchain fixture's
request/header line is re-compacted so the header-scrub hygiene guard
passes (my earlier patch had re-spaced it). The TUI terminal fixture was
already regenerated from keyless replay in the previous commit.
New tools/code-dispatch-log waterfall (run via registry.shapeDispatchLog,
contained — a throwing listener falls back to the unshaped content) lets
listeners reshape the tool/code-dispatch event's content before the
bridge appends it. dsh-spill-policy registers a second arm sharing the
model-facing arm's exact replacement pipeline (same maxInlineBytes cap,
preview + locator, within-cap invariant, best-effort fallbacks), with
artifacts labeled dispatch under the sub-call id. The program's value is
untouched; read sub-calls ARE bounded (a log copy is not model context,
and read produces the biggest logs). Resolves the tools README's
uncapped-dispatch-log Known Limitation.
The bridge replaces its serialization queue with a pool that reuses the
native concurrency contract: submissions classify through
registry.executionMode (fail-closed isConcurrencySafe), start strictly in
submission order, overlap up to the validated maxParallelSubCalls config
(default 10; 1 restores serial), and exclusive calls drain the pool, run
alone, and bar later calls. Each started sub-call logs a
tool/code-dispatch-start event at pool entry; the existing
tool/code-dispatch settles the pair (started ⇔ settles exactly once;
abandoned queued calls log neither). SDK prompt guidance now states the
true Promise.all contract — re-recorded across every code/both-mode
snapshot (plus the stale cordis-dynamic-toolchain fixture gaining the
required description arg).
Client: CodeSubCall widens to RunningToolCall | ToolResultNode — starts
land the running shape (rows wear the native running ring), settles
replace in place preserving start order, callTime pairs to the start
time. Fixture emits start/settle pairs; jsdom pins the running sub-row;
runtime specs pin in-place settlement and out-of-order completion.
run_code gains a required bash-style description parameter: presentCall
titles the card with it and moves the program to rawInput, so every
surface gets a readable label. tool/code-dispatch now logs each
sub-call's complete content/isError (the tool/result vocabulary),
replacing the bounded resultSummary and deleting the summarize/cwd
machinery — a UI renders sub-calls through the identical path as native
results. The dsh config tree mounts the worker code runtime and reads
DSH_TOOLS_MODE (temporary seam until per-session mode selection lands).
Session format stays v0 (pre-release churn). Code-mode ACP/TUI fixtures
re-recorded; TUI presenter pin refreshed; catalogs regenerated. Keyless
web smoke pins the code-mode wire contract (tools=[run_code] + SDK
prompt section).
Tianyi Cui