The snapshot tier was built single-session: dsh-llm-replay served calls from
one global positional cursor, and the harness harvested one session log. A
subagent runs as a second agent with its own session, so a parent→child
scenario could neither replay deterministically nor harvest the child's log.
This resolves the TODO(subagent-snapshots) deferral from the subagent RFC.
- Stamp the calling session id onto the model request: GenerateOptions.sessionId
(typed Branded<'SessionId'> to avoid the dsh-llm↔dsh-session cycle), set by the
agent loop from agent.session.id. Adapters ignore it; an llm/stream listener
routes by it.
- Key replay per session: dsh-llm-replay loads the parent log plus one per child
(childFiles / $DSH_SNAPSHOT_CHILD_FILES), derives a script per recorded session,
and binds each live (freshly-random) session to a recorded script by first-call
order — parent first (earliest createdAt, first to stream). Keys by WHO calls,
so it survives a future concurrent/backgrounded subagent; a global cursor would
not. An unrecorded extra session fails loud.
- Harvest every log: the harness collects all .jsonl across cwd buckets, ordered
primary-first (top-level, then children by createdAt), and RunResult exposes the
plural sessionLogs. The spec writes each back on record (session.jsonl +
session.<n>.jsonl) and diffs each against its fixture on replay.
- Wire the subagent seam + spawn + fork + tool into the acp-agent example (both
cordis configs) and add two nested scenarios recorded against the real API:
subagent-spawn (parent + 1 child) and subagent-multi (parent + 2 children, 3
sessions). Both replay keyless in the default gate.
A new RFC documents the design (docs/rfc/implemented/testing/). Single-session
replay is unchanged (a call with no sessionId is one anonymous primary session).
TODO follow-up: a dedicated branded-ids package could own the SessionId brand and
dissolve the cross-package cycle note; out of scope for this testing PR.
A request signal aborted BEFORE the run starts never fires an `abort` event
(`addEventListener` only fires on the transition), so the backend-level bridge
missed it and ran the child to `completed`. The driver now checks
`request.signal?.aborted` at the top of the result path and settles `aborted`
without running the child. Regression test proven red on the pre-fix code.
Also refresh two stale RFC prose blocks the round-1 fix left behind: the
subagent RFC's Problem statement (cited the removed `TODO(sub-agents)` markers
and claimed nothing existed yet) and the unify-id RFC's fork/spawn risk bullet
(described the seam as "explicitly deferred" via `AgentLoop.create`'s old TODO),
now pointing at the realized seam.
Two merge-blocking bugs in the shared in-process run driver, both rooted in
`readResult` scanning the whole child session and deriving the stop reason only
from `turn/end`:
- A pre-turn `cancel()` cleared the queued prompt before any `turn/end` was
logged, so the run settled `error` instead of `aborted`, violating the
`SubagentRun.cancel()` contract. The driver now tracks that a cancel was
requested and maps the no-turn case to `aborted`.
- A fork child whose own turn produced no `assistant/message` returned the
SEEDED parent's last message as a `completed` success. `readResult` now scopes
to the child's OWN events (after the seed prefix), so a message-less child
yields empty output.
Both fixes carry a regression test proven to go red on the pre-fix driver.
Also: correct the `SubagentRun.id` / event-payload docs (it is the child AGENT
id, not a session id — the backend mints distinct tokens); refresh the stale
`coding-agent` welcome string (subagent is now a tool); and replace the stale
`TODO(sub-agents)` "deferred" prose in the Agent interface, core.md, and
architecture.md with an accurate pointer to the realized seam.
The second PR of the subagent seam: the two in-process backends that run a
child agent on the same cordis context, reusing the agent factory's quiescent
AgentHandle teardown. Both register on ctx.subagents (PR1's named-provider
registry) and share one run driver.
- dsh-subagent-spawn: a FRESH child via ctx.agents.create — own session, the
parent's model by default (overridable), zero inherited conversation. Also
exports the shared in-process run driver (startInProcessRun): mint ids, stamp
cwd/parentSession-lineage/depth, drive the one-shot (send → whenIdle), read
the last assistant/message + turn/end reason, dispose to quiescence.
- dsh-subagent-fork: a child SEEDED with the parent's balanced completed-turn
prefix (the log up to and including its last turn/end), so the child inherits
context. The in-flight unbalanced turn is excluded — a raw seed would fail the
invariants replay. Proven: a regression test goes red if the boundary seeds
the open turn.
- Seam extension: CreateAgentOptions.seed, threaded through AgentLoop.createAgent
→ ctx.sessions.prepare({ seed }) (the primitive resume already used). This is
the fork-lineage path the TODO(sub-agents) markers anticipated.
- Depth: a merge-extensible AgentOptions.subagentDepth (0 top-level, parent+1 for
a child); the depthLimit capability refuses a spawn past request.maxDepth.
Tests: real-loop unit tests for both backends (mock MODEL only, real loop +
invariants), a multi-subagent test (one parent drives a fork AND a spawn child
then keeps working), and a with-key e2e (a real parent delegates via the
`subagent` tool to a real child that writes a file on disk — world-verified).
100% per-file coverage. The coding-agent demo wires the spawn backend + tool.
Snapshot coverage of nested agents is deferred to a stacked follow-up
(TODO(subagent-snapshots)): dsh-llm-replay is a single global positional cursor
that cannot route calls to a parent vs. a child on one context. Recorded in the
RFC's deferrals and a new AGENTS.md rule: designing a subsystem must design its
test infrastructure END TO END up front, verifying the snapshot/e2e harness can
express the new shape — a gap this plan hit.
A single try/catch around ctx.emit prevented a thrown subagent/start or
subagent/end listener from propagating, but cordis emit dispatches listeners in
a `.map(cb => cb())` that HALTS on the first throw — so a bad subscriber still
starved the listeners registered after it, violating the AGENTS.md
callback-boundary rule ("one bad subscriber must not starve the listeners after
it"). Resolve the listener callbacks via ctx.events.dispatch and contain each
call individually, the same per-listener guarantee BashExecutor.notifyTaskDone
gives its own listener set.
The two containment tests now register TWO listeners where the first throws and
assert the second still observes the event (start) and the settle (end) — a
regression that fails on the per-emit code (verified: reverted, watched both go
red, restored).
Address four findings from the first Codex review round:
- Contain subagent/start|end listener throws (emitContainedStart/End): a
thrown lifecycle listener could escape SubagentService.start() before the
caller received the live run to dispose it (a leaked child), and a thrown
subagent/end listener could surface as an unhandled rejection on the detached
result-settle hook. Both emits now log-and-contain, mirroring the agent
registry's agent/created|disposed containment.
- Make the model-facing tool name configurable (Config.toolName, default
subagent). The docs say to load dsh-tool-subagent once per provider to expose
multiple transports, but the hardcoded name made the second load throw a
duplicate-tool-name error; a distinct toolName per load is now required and
documented.
- Reach the per-file 100% coverage gate: tests for the subagent/end error
branch, lifecycle-listener containment, every stopReasonError arm + the
merge-extensible default, the multi-provider toolName path, agentOptions
forwarding, and the direct-apply schema-bypass fallbacks.
- Document the seam vocabulary in docs/core-data-structures/subagent.md with
verbatim type-equiv blocks + manifest entries, and link it from core.md (a
brand-new core/seam type the doc-sync gate cannot detect on its own).
Introduce the `packages/subagent/` group and the abstract subagent seam — an
agent delegating to a child agent — as a named-provider registry (`ctx.subagents`),
unlike the single-implementation bash seam, so multiple transports (in-process,
ACP, future A2A) coexist. This first PR lands the interface, a scripted test
backend, and the model-facing tool, validated through the real cordis load path.
- dsh-subagent: SubagentService registry + SubagentProvider/SubagentRun
vocabulary + subagent/start|end events. Start-time capabilities (outputSchema,
depthLimit, toolFilter) are checked pre-start and rejected loud; runtime
capabilities (sendMessage, resume) are optional methods on SubagentRun.
- dsh-subagent-mock (support): scripted provider for keyless, deterministic
tests through the real Loader/export path.
- dsh-tool-subagent: the model-facing `subagent` tool, config-bound to one
provider; synchronous collect with try/finally dispose, signal->cancel
bridging, and non-completed-stop-reason -> isError mapping.
- Proposed RFC documenting the seam, the fork-vs-spawn-as-separate-backends
decision, own-session isolation, synchronous-collect scope, and the deferral
of background/poll/spill to a future unification with bash.
- Wire the new group into tsconfigs, build refs, package hierarchy docs, the
module graph, and the cordis catalog.
RFC: docs/rfc/proposed/feature/2026-06-21-subagent-capability-seam.md
assertEntriesLoaded() flagged ANY fiber-less entry as a failed import, but a
`disabled: true` entry settles without a fiber by design (Entry.refresh() skips
init() when disabled) — a valid "plugin off" config, not a broken import. Both
app bins now filter `fiber === undefined && !entry.disabled`. The stdio built-bin
smoke gains a disabled-(unresolvable)-entry config that must still boot.
The verify-package-paths lib-skip was unconditional and ran before the
moved-package check, so a stale group-less `packages/acp-agent/lib/bin.js` (the
exact drift this gate catches) was silently ignored just for containing `lib`.
Scope the skip: only exempt `lib` when it is the segment after an EXISTING
`packages/<group>/<pkg>` root, so a real-but-unbuilt `lib/bin.js` is still exempt
while a stale package path flags.
verify-package-paths flagged the new built-bin smokes' `lib/bin.js` citations
as stale-source drift, failing CI: doc-sync runs BEFORE build, so the build
output is absent at lint time. The gate targets moved SOURCE paths, so skip any
reference whose target goes through a `lib/` segment — mirroring how the file
scan already excludes `lib/`.
The acp built-bin smoke resolved `zod`/`@agentclientprotocol/sdk` via
`import.meta.resolve` from the test file's own context, but `acp-agent` does not
declare them — `dsh-acp` does. Under pnpm's strict layout they are not exposed
where the test resolves, so the new CI built-bin step failed with
"Cannot find package 'zod'". Resolve each from the `ui/acp` package URL (the one
that declares it) instead.
BLOCKER — the published lib/bin.js (stdio + acp) was exercised only via tsx
(demo:* / the src/bin.ts smokes); the built artifact under plain `node` was
unguarded. Root-cause on the BUILT bin:
1. Settle race: boot() returned once loader.create() registered the include
ENTRY, but the include loads its child plugins asynchronously — so boot()
(and main()) resolved while the app plugins (stdin reader, agent loop, ACP
bridge) were still mounting. A CLI with no attached handles yet exits 0
silently, and a load error surfaces as an unhandled rejection AFTER boot.
Fix: `await ctx.loader.await()` after create() — settle the whole tree.
2. Config-path robustness: hand the include the config's ABSOLUTE file:// URL
so resolution never depends on ctx.baseUrl / can never fall back to cwd.
Both bins fixed identically. NOTE: the cordis Loader resolves a config's bare
plugin specifiers via its internal module loader, active only under
`node --expose-internals`; the bin cannot add a node flag itself, so this is
documented in the bin JSDoc + both package READMEs (the demos already comply).
The repo `examples/*/cordis.yml` are tsx-only artifacts (workspace plugins
resolve through the tsconfig paths map, not node_modules), so they are not a
valid plain-node bin target — the smokes use a real-install-shaped temp dir.
Fail loud on a load failure: boot() previously exited 0 SILENTLY when a config
path's directory does not exist — the include plugin fails to IMPORT, the cordis
Loader catches+LOGS it and leaves the entry with no fiber (no rejection), and
`loader.await()` does not rethrow (EntryTree.await uses Promise.allSettled). Fix:
boot() now calls assertEntriesLoaded(ctx) after the tree settles and throws on
any entry with no fiber, so a typo'd config dir exits non-zero with a clear
message. main() also installs an unhandledRejection guard (installFailLoud) that
replaces Node's stack dump with a single labelled stderr line for the
companion case (a missing config FILE in a real dir, whose include-init throw
surfaces as a rejection Node already exits non-zero on). Regression tests added
to both built-bin smokes (missing dir + missing file → non-zero exit + stderr);
verified the missing-dir test fails on the pre-fix bin.
Built-bin smokes (the reviewer's ask): packages/ui/{stdio,acp}-agent/tests/
built-bin.e2e.ts run the REAL lib/bin.js under `node` (NOT tsx) in a temp
consumer dir, asserting the stdio echo round-trip / the acp initialize response
+ stdout purity, plus the fail-loud cases above. They build-gate (skip if lib/
absent) and run in a new ci.yml step after the build.
Issue 2 — packages/README.md + docs/architecture.md said "plugins depend on
interfaces, never on the concrete loop", but dsh-agent-core imports the concrete
dsh-agent-loop. Scope the rule to EXTENSION plugins and carve out the sanctioned
COMPOSITION/bundle exception (dsh-agent-core composes the concrete spine); note
it in the implemented RFC too.
Issue 3 — examples/acp-agent/tests/acp.snapshot.ts fixture-guard claimed
no-model scenarios need no session.jsonl, but runScenario() always boots
llm-replay with the session.jsonl path and loadReplayScript() throws when it is
absent. Require session.jsonl for ALL scenarios (no-model ones ship a
header-only fixture) and rewrite the comment to match reality.
The acp-agent README/RFC overclaim was already softened; this module doc comment
still said the footgun is "structurally unreachable from the leaf". A leaf
cordis.yml CAN still add a sibling @cordisjs/plugin-logger-console — the app does
not prevent it. Reword to the accurate claim: the app gives the default front
door no logger entry to misconfigure, and the "never add a stdout logger to an
ACP leaf" rule still stands.
Codex review of PR #88 found three issues in the example-app extraction:
A1 — examples/coding-agent/README.md's plugin table still listed the OLD
direct-wired leaf entries (agent-loop, session-persistence, src/stdio-chat.ts —
the whole src/ dir is gone). Rewrite it to the four real leaf entries the
current cordis.yml loads (hmr, llm-deepseek, bash, stdio-agent), noting that
tool-bash/persistence/agent/loop now live inside the agent-core + stdio-agent
bundles.
A2 — the three new app/spine packages (agent-core, stdio-agent, acp-agent)
export NO `inject`, so a stray `export default apply` would let unwrapExports
collapse the module and silently DROP name/Config WITHOUT crashing — the
real-load-path smokes would stay green. agent-core is never Loader-unwrapped at
all. Add an explicit export-shape guard per package: assert no `default` export
and that the real Loader.unwrapExports leaves name/Config/apply intact. Verified
each fails when `export default apply` is added.
B — soften "structurally unreachable / cannot wire a stdout logger" overclaims
in the acp-agent/agent-core READMEs and the implemented RFC: a leaf CAN still add
a sibling logger entry; the accurate claim is the app omits one so the default
leaf has nothing to get wrong. Keep the safety directive (never add a stdout
logger to an ACP leaf).
Implements docs/rfc/.../2026-06-20-extract-example-app-packages.md. Each
example was thick — a hand-rolled start.ts, an infra preamble, nested
base.yml/base-core.yml/acp-tail.yml includes, and a coupled front-door
cluster enforced only by prose. This moves the composition into packages so
each example is a thin leaf cordis.yml: pick the swappable backends, load one
app package.
New packages:
- @deepseek-ai/dsh-agent-core (packages/core/agent-core): one bundle plugin
that loads the providerless/executor-less/UI-less spine (timer + llm +
sessions + system-prompt + tools + agents + invariants + tool-bash +
agent-loop) via ctx.plugin(...) inside apply(), and forwards agent-loop's
`agents` list as its own Config (export const Config = AgentLoop.Config,
default []).
- @deepseek-ai/dsh-stdio-agent (packages/ui/stdio-agent): terminal chat APP —
agent-core + console logger + readline UI + a pre-created `main` agent, with
a bin. The demo:echo/coding front door.
- @deepseek-ai/dsh-acp-agent (packages/ui/acp-agent): ACP server APP —
agent-core + JSONL persistence + the acp bridge, NO stdout logger, with a
bin. The stdout-purity footgun is structurally unreachable from the leaf.
Amendment to the RFC: hmr stays a LEAF cordis.yml entry, not baked into
dsh-stdio-agent. hmr is a Loader-only dev plugin (throws without
--expose-internals; the in-process test tier can't even import its decorator
form), so a package statically importing it could never carry the per-file
coverage gate. Unlike the console logger, a stray hmr is not a stdout-purity
footgun, so leaving it at the leaf costs no safety. With hmr out, all three new
packages carry in-process unit specs at 100%.
Boot glue (Loader tail, .env load, snapshot-mode selection, stdin-dispose
lifecycle) moves into each app's bin; start.ts and base.yml/base-core.yml/
acp-tail.yml are deleted. Each app package gets a keyless real-load-path test
that boots through its bin + the cordis Loader (guarding the unwrapExports
export-shape bug class, postmortem 0001). ACP snapshot replay stays green
against the existing committed goldens (pure boot restructuring). RFC moved
proposed->implemented with the amendment recorded; package/example/architecture
docs and the module graph updated.
Codex's re-confirmation pass verified both blocker fixes correct but found
doc/comment drift the fix commit missed:
- session/index.ts + session/README.md: "minimal v1 header" → "minimal header
(stamped with the current SESSION_FORMAT_VERSION)" — the version is 0, not 1.
- session/index.ts deriveMessages comment listed "usage, and errors" as trace
data — those standalone events no longer exist; only boundaries + chunks are.
- session-persistence RFC: "no v1 migration" → the pinned-v0 pre-release stance.
- collapse-trace-only RFC format-version note: reframed off the "bump the
version and reject" wording (which now reads as the OTHER AGENTS.md stance)
onto the pinned-0 unstable stance the session log actually uses.
- agent-loop/loop.ts finishError JSDoc: "with a logged `error` event" → the
failure is recorded on turn/end.reason (no standalone error event).
- acp/acp-feature-support.md (two spots): usage is recorded on assistant/message
now, not as standalone internal usage events.
- Regenerate the cordis catalog (finishError JSDoc line shift).
Codex review of the trace-event fold found two merge-blockers.
Blocker #1 — format version. Folding usage onto assistant/message and removing
the standalone usage/error events changed the persisted SessionEventMap shape,
which per the AGENTS.md "bump the version and reject — don't migrate" policy
requires a backend to reject any non-current log. Centralize the version in an
exported SESSION_FORMAT_VERSION constant (dsh-session), read by both write sites
(Session constructor default, SessionStore.prepare header) and the coordinator's
load-time assertVersion check. The constant is pinned at 0: while unreleased the
on-disk format is unstable/pre-release, so breaking shape churn is absorbed at v0
(no monotonic bump until the first tagged release) and any non-0 log is rejected
on load — no migration. Update every test/fixture/doc that stamps a
currently-written header to the constant, bump the ACP snapshot fixture + golden
headers to v0, and keep the version-rejection test meaningful by switching its
bad value to a clearly non-current 99. AGENTS.md documents both the monotonic
(SQLite SCHEMA_VERSION) and pinned-0 (session log) pre-release stances.
Blocker #2 — restore the late turn-end warn. failTurn now sets the error reason
only while the turn is still open; once turn/end is appended (a throwing
agent/turn-end listener after closeTurn) the reason can no longer reach the
durable log, so the late throw is logged via ctx.logger.warn instead of
vanishing into a futile post-close assignment. A regression test asserts the
warn fires.
Also guard the normal-step assistant/message append with the same
content-or-usage condition as the max-tokens branch (a content-less, usage-less
step records no trace-only row), with a covering test.
Adding packages/util/brand/ created a new top-level packages/util/ group that
the hierarchy/dependency docs never enumerated. Document it:
- Add packages/util/README.md, the group README (low-level zero-dependency
utilities shared across groups; lists dsh-brand).
- packages/README.md: add the util/ group to the group table, dsh-brand to the
package table, and dsh-brand to the dependency graph. Correct the now-false
"no harness deps" claims — dsh-llm and dsh-bash both depend on dsh-brand
(verified dsh-bash imports Branded from dsh-brand, not dsh-llm; dsh-session
and dsh-agent depend on it too).
- Root AGENTS.md Repository Layout: add the util/ group with brand/.
Align the implemented branded-ids RFC with what shipped: Branded lives in
@deepseek-ai/dsh-brand (packages/util/brand/), and dsh-bash depends only on
that utility package instead of dsh-llm. Fix the BashTaskId import source, the
illustrative snippet, and the opening policy reference (now dsh-brand).
The whenIdle() JSDoc cited "a closing ACP connection" as a non-owner that
awaits whenIdle(). That is false against the code: ACP OWNS its agent handles
and tears them down via rec.dispose()/handle.dispose() (quiesce() at
packages/ui/acp/src/index.ts:666-686), never whenIdle(). The only whenIdle()
consumers are tests (acp dispose/turns/edges specs, agent specs) — which is
genuinely why the primitive stays (a test harness programs against the seam),
but the contract doc must not claim a production ACP path uses it.
Replace the parenthetical with truthful non-owning observers (a test awaiting a
turn to settle, a monitor) and state explicitly that an OWNER does not need
whenIdle() because AgentHandle.dispose() already awaits the loop-exit promise.
- packages/core/agent/src/types.ts: the Agent.whenIdle() contract JSDoc.
- docs/core-data-structures/core.md: the type-equiv mirror (re-copied verbatim).
- Regenerate the cordis catalog (whenIdle source line shifted).
Codex's confirmation pass found the teardown-framing error went deeper than the
three prose spots already fixed: the whenIdle() JSDoc itself (and its mirrors)
claimed "the quiescence signal a teardown awaits ... a lifecycle owner disposes
the agent through its AgentHandle which ... awaits THIS". The disposer does not
call whenIdle() — it does `stop(); await agent.done` directly
(packages/core/agent-loop/src/index.ts:271). whenIdle() is the NON-OWNER
observation hook; owner teardown awaits the loop-exit promise (done) through
AgentHandle.dispose(). Reframe every copy accordingly:
- packages/core/agent/src/types.ts: the Agent.whenIdle() contract JSDoc.
- packages/core/agent-loop/src/agent.ts: the impl JSDoc.
- packages/core/agent/README.md and docs/core-data-structures/core.md (the
type-equiv mirror of the types.ts JSDoc — re-copied verbatim).
- docs/rfc/proposed/feature/2026-06-14-acp-agent-client-protocol.md:40 and :70:
owner teardown via AgentHandle.dispose(); a non-owner observing quiescence
uses the interface-level agent.whenIdle(), not hand-rolled agent/status.
- Regenerate the cordis catalog (whenIdle source line moved).
The session event vocabulary carried two standalone trace-only events that
were not load-bearing as separate records. Fold their facts into nearby
load-bearing events and delete the standalone variants.
- Token usage now rides on `assistant/message` as an optional `usage` field —
the assembled model output and its accounting travel together. The loop folds
`assembler.usage` onto the append instead of emitting a separate `usage`
event.
- The max-tokens path is the no-data-loss host: a step cut off with usage but
EMPTY content (e.g. only a dropped tool call) previously emitted a standalone
`usage`; it now records an empty-content `assistant/message { content: [],
usage }`. `deriveMessages()` skips empty-content assistant messages, so the
usage host never injects a spurious content-less assistant turn into the
provider transcript. A step with neither content nor usage appends nothing.
- An operational error's step number now rides on `turn/end.reason` for
`kind: 'error'` (`{ kind: 'error', step, message, code? }`) — the durable
turn outcome ACP and resume already consume. `failTurn` sets the reason
directly (no separate session `error` event). `agent/error` + logging are
unchanged for live diagnostics.
- No format-version bump: pre-release, no persisted data, so per the format
policy there is nothing to migrate or reject (the RFC's "refresh the format
version" criterion over-reached). `version` stays 1.
- ACP fixtures + goldens re-recorded (keyless replay): dropped standalone
usage/error lines, usage folded onto assistant/message, error step on
turn/end.reason.
RFC moved proposed -> implemented with an implementation note recording the two
scope refinements.
Codex's no-ship was a completeness/docs-sync gap, not loop behavior:
- docs/architecture.md: drop the public abort() handle row; the teardown
signal is now cancel() then await whenIdle().
- cancel.spec.ts: the module doc and the turn-start comment contrasted
cancel() against a public abort() verb that no longer exists — reword to
name the loop's private step AbortController.
- packages/ui/acp/src/index.ts: the post-resume-leak comment cited abort();
cancel() is the surviving stop verb that likewise does not unregister.
- Move the RFC proposed -> implemented/simplification with amended text:
Status flips, the both-removal proposal is narrowed to abort-only, and an
implementation note records why whenIdle() is retained (load-bearing
quiescence primitive with live ACP consumers). Update docs/rfc/README.md.
- AGENTS.md "RFCs are proposals, not golden truth": add the concrete
abort/whenIdle worked example now that the implemented RFC exists to link.
- Regenerate the cordis catalog (line-number drift from the rebase).
The public Agent handle exposed abort() (step-only) and cancel() (queue-aware).
No production caller used abort() — ACP maps session/cancel to cancel(), and
lifecycle owners tear down via AgentHandle.dispose(); the loop's own stop paths
abort their per-step AbortController directly. So abort() is latent generality
that keeps a private loop mechanic public.
RFC-premise correction: the public-agent-stop-surface RFC proposed removing
whenIdle() too. Implementation found whenIdle() load-bearing — a real
quiescence primitive with a deliberate loop contract (settle-without-transition,
the replacement-turn race) and ACP test consumers; its proposed replacement
("observe the running->idle transition") is exactly the async-state race
AGENTS.md warns against. So only abort() is removed; whenIdle() stays. The RFC
is amended on the way to implemented/ to record the narrowed scope, and the new
AGENTS.md "RFCs are proposals, not golden truth" principle (PR1) gets its
worked example.
- Remove Agent.abort() from the interface + the ReactLoopAgent impl; the no-arg
'aborted' default goes with it (cancel() keeps its 'cancelled' default).
- Migrate tests: empty-queue abort() -> cancel(reason); the two review-fixes
tests whose subject is the in-flight step's AbortController drive that
controller directly via the private currentAbort field (cancel() would clear
the inbox and destroy the queued steering one of them proves survives a step
abort). The no-arg-default test is dropped (cancel()'s default is already
covered in cancel.spec.ts).
- Resulting public stop surface: cancel() + whenIdle(). Update agent/agent-loop
READMEs, architecture.md, core.md type-equiv, the extension cookbook, the
lifecycle RFC (short note), and the proposed ACP RFC.
Implements docs/rfc/implemented/simplification/2026-06-20-public-agent-stop-surface.md
Type-only change (brands are zero-cost casts; no runtime/wire impact). Closes
the two gaps in the "brand ids that cross package boundaries" policy and fixes
the dependency direction so a capability package never pulls in an unrelated one.
- Extract the `Branded<B>` primitive into a new standalone type-only package
`@deepseek-ai/dsh-brand` (packages/util/brand) with no harness-package deps.
dsh-llm keeps its owned CallId but imports Branded from dsh-brand; dsh-session,
dsh-agent, and dsh-bash all import Branded from there. dsh-bash depends on
dsh-brand ALONE — never on dsh-llm or dsh-session (the architectural fix: a
generic execution backend must not couple to the LLM or session vocabulary).
- Mint BashTaskId + OwnerToken in dsh-bash and thread them through BashTask.id,
the get/ownerOf/list/readOutput/kill seam, the bash-local generation site, and
the dsh-tool-bash validate/access surface. OwnerToken is a DISTINCT brand from
SessionId so the seam stays decoupled; dsh-tool-bash is the single boundary
that casts SessionId -> OwnerToken.
- Brand at the SOURCE, not via mid-pipeline casts: agent-loop's Config types
agents[].id as AgentId and resumeSessionId as SessionId, so the brand enters
at the config boundary and the inner create()/resume casts disappear (only the
genuinely-new per-run session-id string is cast).
- Stop brand erosion: propagate CallId/SessionId/AgentId to the registry/store
Map keys and public params/exports (SessionStore, AgentRegistry + factory
options, the ACP session-id surface + ToolPresenter CallId map, the
persistence coordinator, invariants pendingCalls, the pi-ai tool-call maps).
- Docs: document BashTaskId/OwnerToken in bash.md (type-equiv re-pasted), point
the Branded type-equiv at dsh-brand, fix stale param types in the session/
agent/bash READMEs, regenerate the cordis catalog + module graph.
Implements docs/rfc/proposed/architecture/2026-06-20-branded-ids.md
The original prune removed BashExecutor.get()/.list() too, but each is a
one-line accessor over the executor's already-tracked tasks map, and removing
them forced dsh-tool-bash's tests onto a ~35-line onTaskDone completion-tracking
harness just to replace the one-line ctx.bash.get(id) lookup. Per the AGENTS.md
"RFCs are proposals, not golden truth" principle, that disproportionate
migration cost is evidence the methods earn their keep — a test harness IS a
consumer programming against the seam.
Restore get()/list() (seam + LocalBashExecutor impl + the bash tests that used
them, dropping the doneFor/trackCompletions scaffolding). The persistence
has()/delete()/deleteStored removal stands — it had only contract-test callers
and no test-ergonomics cost. The RFC is retitled persistence-only with an
implementation note recording the bash revert.
Second Codex pass caught two proposed RFCs that describe the bash seam as it
WAS (with get/list) and would read stale once this prune lands, plus a latent
test-helper edge:
- docs/rfc/proposed/architecture/2026-06-20-branded-ids.md and
2026-06-20-generic-long-running-tool-runtime.md: drop get/list from the
BashExecutor seam description (surviving: resolve/run/start/ownerOf/
readOutput/kill/onTaskDone). branded-ids will be further updated when it is
implemented; this keeps it accurate in the meantime.
- trackCompletions now records every completion to `done` unconditionally (and
also wakes a parked waiter), so a second doneFor(id) after completion resolves
instead of hanging.
Codex review of the PR2 diff caught doc/comment sites doc-sync does not gate
(core-data-structures prose) and a latent test-helper race:
- docs/core-data-structures/persistence.md + bash.md, sqlite README, and two
source comments (coordinator.ts, jsonl.spec.ts) still listed the removed
has/delete/get/list methods — updated to the surviving four-method
persistence surface and the get/list-free bash seam.
- doneFor(ctx, id) attached its onTaskDone listener lazily, after the task
could already have closed (e.g. `true`), so it could miss the completion and
hang. Replaced with trackCompletions(ctx): one eagerly-installed listener
(mounted in setup() before any task starts) records every completion, and
doneFor resolves immediately for an already-finished task or on completion
otherwise. Race-free, and there is no get-by-id seam left to poll instead.
Two capability seams carried abstract methods no production consumer calls.
A method no consumer programs against is not a seam — it is speculative
surface every implementation must still provide and test.
- SessionPersistence: remove has() and delete(), the coordinator's
has/delete/deleteCore, and the PersistenceBackend.deleteStored hook (with its
jsonl + sqlite + in-spec memory-stub impls). Surviving service surface:
create/append/load/list. Production uses only load() (resume) and list()
(ACP session/list).
- BashExecutor: remove get(id) and list(), the abstract decls and the
LocalBashExecutor impls. The internal tasks map survives (it backs
ownerOf/readOutput/kill); get/list were pure public accessors over it with no
shipping caller and no bash_list tool.
- Migrate tests that reached through ctx.bash.get(id) to the public completion
seam: a doneFor(id) helper over onTaskDone awaits a task by id, and the
HMR-reload ownership test now proves task survival through A's own bash_output
([status: running]) plus ownerOf + B-rejection — a stronger through-the-tool
assertion than the removed lookup peek.
- Update seam READMEs (six -> four service methods, drop the deleteStored hook
and the get/list row) and the two implemented persistence RFCs in place.
Implements docs/rfc/implemented/simplification/2026-06-20-prune-dead-seam-methods.md
Codex review of the PR1 diff surfaced docs/cleanup drift:
- LlmService class JSDoc still advertised "streaming / non-streaming call
surfaces, both interceptable via waterfall events" — corrected to the single
streaming surface; regenerated the cordis catalog so its mirror updates.
- Removed GenerateResult from gen-cordis-catalog.ts LINK_MAP (the type is gone).
- The adapter-change RFC's acceptance criterion named the retired
verify-event-taxonomy gate; updated to verify-cordis-catalog.
- Dropped the now-tautological "streaming and one-shot assembly agree" property
test (the streaming/one-shot distinction lived in the removed flush API;
usage/finish remain covered by assembler.spec.ts and the finish property).
The LLM service exposed three call surfaces (stream/streamBlocks/generate) but
the only production consumer — the agent loop — uses stream() exclusively,
feeding raw chunks through its own BlockAssembler for replay fidelity. Drop the
speculative convenience surfaces and the registry-change event that no listener
consumed, leaving stream() as the single model-call contract for both
production and tests.
- Remove LlmService.streamBlocks() and generate(), the llm/generate waterfall,
and GenerateResult.
- Remove the llm/adapter-change event (declaration + emits) and the
listener-throw rollback ordering that existed only to protect it; keep the
HMR rollback disposer.
- Remove BlockAssembler.flushReady()/flushRemaining()/result() and the flushed
cursor — the streaming-flush slice existed only for streamBlocks().
- Adapter tests drive a stream()+BlockAssembler helper (tests/assemble.ts)
instead of generate(), exercising the same path production uses.
- Land the AGENTS.md "RFCs are proposals, not golden truth" principle and move
both RFCs proposed -> implemented.
Implements:
- docs/rfc/implemented/simplification/2026-06-20-drop-unconsumed-llm-adapter-change-event.md
- docs/rfc/implemented/simplification/2026-06-20-drop-unconsumed-llm-assembled-surfaces.md
Add a README to each group dir (core/llm/bash/session-persistence/ui/
support) stating its role and product-vs-support classification, and
rewrite packages/README.md around the hierarchy (group table, grouped
"what goes where", removed the package-hierarchy FIXME).
Move the package-hierarchy RFC to implemented/architecture/ and rewrite
it to describe what shipped (placement rationale, the paths-wildcard and
publint dedup, the two new guardrail gates). Fold the remaining
tsconfig.build.json references dedup into the discover-package-inventory
proposal and fix its cross-link.
Update AGENTS.md: regrouped repo-layout map, depth-2 globs, the new
verify-package-paths gate in the doc-sync listing, and a note that we
lean toward stricter lint in the agentic-coding era (machine-caught
errors and a consistent foundation outweigh the one-time cost).
Merge brought in the RFC-classification reorg and two new doc gates;
rewrite every drifted packages/<name> cross-link (Markdown link targets,
moved-README relative depths, and .ts comment paths) to the grouped paths.
Add two doc-sync/hygiene gates so the manual checks this restructure
needed become automated:
- verify-package-paths.ts: flags a packages/<path> reference (in Markdown
or a .ts comment/string) that does not resolve AND names a real package
in a segment — i.e. a stale path to a MOVED package. A path naming a
non-existent package (a forward-looking proposal) is left alone, so it
applies uniformly across proposed/implemented/rejected.
- check-workspace-constraints: assert the packages/<group>/<pkg> depth-2
shape (group dirs carry no package.json; no flat or over-nested
packages). Group names stay open; only the shape is fixed.
Move the 18 flat packages/<name> packages into role-grouped dirs:
core/, llm/, bash/, session-persistence/, ui/, support/. Group dirs are
pure containers; each package keeps its @deepseek-ai/dsh-* name.
Collapse the per-package tsconfig paths maps (base + typecheck) into one
@deepseek-ai/dsh-* wildcard with a candidate per group, and derive the
publint list from the hierarchy. Update all depth-coupled globs/configs
(workspace, tsdown, vitest, eslint, knip, tsconfig includes/refs,
per-package tsconfigs, generators, doc-script scopes, type-equiv manifest)
and the cross-package/script relative imports in tests.
Fix doc-typecheck's workspacePaths() to parse tsconfig JSONC via the
TypeScript API instead of a regex comment-strip, which corrupted the
new wildcard `/*/` path candidates.
WIP: doc cross-links and package/RFC docs still to update.
Add a second axis to every RFC — its class (feature, bug-fix,
simplification, architecture, process, testing) — encoded in the path
as docs/rfc/{lifecycle}/{class}/file.md. The folder is the label, so
the closed set is enforced by structure rather than a parsed field.
Two new doc-sync gates back it:
- verify-rfc-classification: every RFC sits in a valid class folder and
the README index lists it under the matching lifecycle→class heading.
- verify-doc-refs: every docs/*.md path cited in a packages|examples TS
comment resolves — closes a drift class verify-md-links can't see, and
catches the four comment refs this reorg moved.
The README gains a Classification section explaining the taxonomy and
per-class index sub-sections. A self-referential process RFC records why
the scheme is path-encoded and gated.
Add scripts/gen-cordis-catalog.ts: a fully-generated docs/cordis-catalog/
events-and-services.md cataloging every cordis event (exact signature + @mode)
and ctx.<key> service (exact interface), modeled on gen-module-graph's
--write/--check freshness gate. The harness tier renders in full from the
interface Events / interface Context declarations and their JSDoc; the inherited
cordis-core/loader/hmr/timer surface renders tersely from a curated table.
The generator hard-errors on a missing @mode tag and on a tag that contradicts
a conclusive signature shape (a trailing next param is structurally a
waterfall). Signature blocks use a ts cordis-catalog fence that doc-typecheck
skips. Type tokens cross-link to the core-data-structures catalog.
This supersedes the hand-maintained event-taxonomy table: verify-event-taxonomy
is deleted and verify-cordis-catalog joins doc-sync. architecture.md keeps the
Event taxonomy heading (TOC anchor) but points at the catalog; the Service-map
role table stays. RFC, AGENTS.md @mode authoring rule, and dependent doc/skill
references updated. Negative gate tests cover the missing-tag and
tag/shape-contradiction paths.
Annotate all 24 harness events across the 5 event-declaring packages with
an explicit `@mode emit|waterfall|parallel` tag and self-contained JSDoc, so
the generated cordis catalog can render each entry's mode and prose from
source alone.
Co-locate the ACP feature support checklist with the bridge package
(packages/acp/acp-feature-support.md) and rewrite its relative links for
the new depth. Broaden the doc-sync globs (doc-typecheck, verify-md-wrap,
verify-md-links) from packages/*/README.md to packages/*/*.md so a
package-level doc beyond the README stays under the drift gates, and
update the AGENTS.md prose describing that scope.
Tianyi Cui
imccyu