Plan mode is entered through /plan only — the select control is retired.
The conversation.input.plan seat (now right of the access-mode control)
renders a read-only Plan chip while the projection's effective target is
plan mode; its hover x executes /plan off, and the chip follows the folded
target (appears on /plan immediately, disappears on /plan off) with frames
correcting either way. While plan mode is targeted the composer textarea's
placeholder switches to the plan-task wording — InputBar reads the same
projection through the standard-kit useProjection (the TodoDock posture:
a type-only key merge, no domain service edge), and owner placeholders
still win.
- Regenerate the cordis/config catalogs, doc graphs, and module graph for
the four newly mounted plugins and the goal projection key.
- ui-goal README pair (Model Experience indirect + Known Limitations) with
its i18n record; sentence-allowlist entry for the indirect form.
- knip workspace entry for ui-goal (tsx test pattern).
- type-equiv manifest follows the seven host-coupled goal symbols to
domain.ts.
- The web-slash-command-dispatch note documents the dropped prompt
interception and leaves with it; the goal-bar note's code paths follow the
component into ui-goal (pairing re-recorded).
The summary blank bit switches from log emptiness to the absence of any
turn/start: standalone plugin events — command lifecycle records,
plan/mode, session titles, goal metadata — no longer surface a fresh
session in lists or steal the New Session view. Running /plan (or /goal)
on a blank session keeps it blank and reusable; the first accepted
prompt's turn clears it. Both carriers share one predicate (summarize +
the host/session-added frame); the cold path keeps its constant false
with the index-read rationale; the client mirror already flips only on
prompt acceptance and needed no change.
set() on an idle agent appends plan/mode at once — no request boundary
would arrive until the next prompt, so a queued intent used to hang as
pending forever (the composer showed a dead pending target). A running
agent keeps the boundary-flush path unchanged. set() now reports which
branch ran (committed/queued/cancelled/noop); the /plan handler's copy
follows the branch (idle: "Plan mode on/off", mid-turn: the next-step
wording), and both commit paths share the header-delta narration. The
invariant drops turn enclosure: plan/mode is a standalone whole-value
event (the synthetic log-only turns removal already established the
between-turns append shape). The fixture mirrors the idle commit.
The persisted row (sessionId, key, stateVersion, observedSeq, state)
becomes (sessionId, key, ver, seq, val) — the cache medium repeats these
three names for every unit of every session, so the long forms dominated
the JSON payload. ProjectionCheckpointRow and the checkpointRow zod spec
rename together; the domain spec bumps to v3 (cache semantics: the old
medium is discarded, not migrated). The unit-facing declaration keeps
stateVersion — only the persisted/checkpoint row shape changes.
Drop the assertions eslint proved unnecessary (getByRole gains the element
type parameter instead, keeping tsc satisfied), declare the injected
setPlanMode as a function property (the seat face is this-free), and narrow
the fixture's command args without String()'s object stringification arm.
eslint --fix removed the no-unnecessary-type-assertion hits the review
knives introduced; the two await-thenable errors were vi.runAllTicks()
awaits in the cache spec, replaced with advanceTimersByTimeAsync(0) (the
fake-timer-safe microtask drain). Repo-wide eslint, dual-aggregate tsc,
and the focused 100% coverage set all green.
Static: the cache package.json files array matches the workspace
constraint shape, the unused dsh-storage-json devDependency is dropped
(tests run on the memory backend), and docs/module-graph.md is
regenerated for the new package edge.
Coverage: two unreachable branches deleted rather than tested —
coldSnapshot's floor-0 tail reuse (a baseSeq-0 restore never throws and
an unrelated record still carries a usable watermark) and flushSoft's
non-mandatory clean-skip (throttle triggers only fire dirty). New tests
close the real gaps: write() on a never-dirty session and the non-JSON
unit-state rejection, plugin disposal clearing armed interval timers,
cachedSnapshot's all-version-mismatched and cwd-identity arms, the
zero-units empty-log cut, the coordinator seek-hook ladder (suffix /
not-found / plain failure / abort-reason relay), and the superseded-
retirement race proving forget()'s exact-entry guard.
Review finding (PR #791): the column carried bare values (no seq), so the
client could not seed its value store without risking a stale list block
outranking newer push frames — and nothing consumed the column at all,
leaving cold titles absent after a restart. SessionSummary.projections is
now the same SessionProjectionsBlock as the history tail (values +
asOfSeq; attached rows cut the live registry, cold rows serve the cache's
identity-checked cachedSnapshot whose asOfSeq is the lowest served-row
watermark). SessionManager.refreshList seeds each row's block into the
per-session projection store via per-key apply — partial-baseline
semantics: an absent key never clears, and higher-seq-wins keeps stale
list blocks beneath push frames and tail baselines — so cold titles
surface in the sidebar without opening a session.
Review finding (PR #791): rows carried only version/watermark/state, so a
recreated session id, or a persistence store replaced under a surviving
cache, could pass every watermark check and seed state folded from an
unrelated log; a checkpoint racing ahead of an eager log flush could
likewise expose values no stored log contains. Records now store the
header identity (createdAt, cwd) they were folded from — reads validate it
against the live header (listing) or the tail's stored header (cold read)
and discard unrelated records whole (domain version 2 discards v1 media by
the pre-release stance). A live checkpoint additionally flushes the
session's buffered events durably before the cache row lands: the cache
can trail the log, never lead it. cachedValues is reshaped into
cachedSnapshot(meta): the identity witness plus the {asOfSeq, values} cut
the list carrier serves.
Review finding (PR #791): with no projection definitions registered,
restoreFloor() is undefined and the fast path returned a successful empty
snapshot without touching persistence — a nonexistent session 'succeeded',
violating the documented not-found contract in that supported topology.
The no-unit branch now probes readFrom(id, 0): an absent log rejects with
the seam's not-found, a present one dates the empty cut at its stored end.
The projection cache surfaced two substrate gaps, both properties of the
domain-KV stack it landed on. (1) The json backend's root is relative and
joined per-open against process.cwd(): sessions are patched global
(~/.dsh/sessions) but workspace.json/session_projcache.json land under
<launch dir>/.storages, splitting derived media from their source of
truth. Proposal: patch storage-json.root to ~/.dsh/storages beside the
session root (profile key storageRoot, mirroring persistenceRoot) and
resolve-once at backend construction, adopting the JSONL backend's
recorded rationale. (2) A damaged cache medium (truncated / version-bumped
/ schema-drifted) bricks fail-loud boot even though its content is fully
rebuildable from session logs. Proposal: DomainSpec grows
recovery: 'reject' | 'reset'; the facility, on exactly the damage-class
errors, destroys a declared-reset medium once and reopens empty —
workspace stays authoritative and loud. Bilingual pair recorded.
gen-cordis-catalog/api, config and persistence catalogs, and doc graphs
regenerated over the new sessionProjectionCache service and the registry's
checkpoint faces. Classifications: ProjectionCheckpoint joins the type-link
exemptions (owned by the projection package source), Partial joins the
foundation names, the cache service gets its capability-seam role row, and
the package takes the one-sentence Model Experience contract (host-side
read-model accelerator, no model surface).
The base's bilingual gate now covers this branch's new README: add the
Chinese counterpart of the session-projection-cache package README, the
cache row on the group README's Chinese side, and re-record the touched
pairs (group, cache, session-persistence — whose English side gained the
readFrom rows earlier on this branch). verify-translation-pairing: 541
pairs consistent.
The watermark cache is the registry's authoritative mutable state; a
checkpoint consumer holding the live reference could corrupt every
subsequent snapshot and frame through it. structuredClone at the read face
(total, by the unit plain-JSON contract) pins the boundary; a mutation test
proves the cache is unreachable through handed-out rows. restore and
viewCheckpoint only touch caller-owned rows — no other leak path.
SessionSummary grows an optional projections column (whole value per key,
same passthrough posture as the history-tail block): attached rows cut the
live registry watermark cache; cold rows view the persisted projection
cache's stored rows via the new registry viewCheckpoint face (version-
matching keys only, zero I/O) — the RFC's motivating scenario, every
session's title across a listing without loading one event log. The column
is fail-soft and absence-coded: no registry, no cache row, or a throwing
read serve the row without the column, never breaking the listing.
New package on the domain data form: one session_projcache record per
session (key → {stateVersion, observedSeq, state}), landing beside
workspace.json under the shipped json backend. Write policy: two mandatory
points (turn/end + session disposal) with count/interval throttling between
them (both Config fields required — flush cadence is a deployment choice);
every background write is fail-soft (log + stay stale, self-heal on the
next write or cold read). coldSnapshot(id) runs the read ladder — cached
rows + persistence readFrom from the registry's anchored restore floor +
registry restore + fail-soft write-back — detecting crash-repair-shrunk
logs via the one-below anchor and degrading to a single full re-read.
Mounted in apps/cli/cordis.yml (writeEveryEvents 200 / writeIntervalMs
5000).
The registry grows the state-level read ladder the persisted cache builds
on: checkpoint(session) snapshots every unit's {stateVersion, observedSeq,
state} row from the watermark cache; restoreFloor(checkpoint) anchors the
tail read one event below the lowest usable watermark (so a shrunk log is
provable); restore(checkpoint, events, baseSeq) refolds each unit from its
usable row (or from init over a full read), rejects rows a tail read cannot
fix (version mismatch / overreach with baseSeq > 0 => re-read from 0), and
returns both the snapshot and the refreshed rows for durable write-back.
ProjectionCheckpointRow/ProjectionCheckpoint are the persisted-row types
minus the record keys.
SessionPersistence grows readFrom(id, fromSeq, signal?): the non-mutating
read-from-seq primitive for checkpoint consumers (the persisted projection
cache folds only the tail past its watermark). Coordinator owns validation,
per-id serialization, and the sequential fallback (loadStored + forward
skip); SQLite implements the optional seek-capable loadStoredFrom hook
(WHERE seq >= ?), JSONL stays sequential by contract. Contract suite covers
suffix exactness, empty-tail, non-mutation, and cancellation; seam README
(both languages) documents the method and the hook.
The simplified inheritance path uses Session creation seeds for policy events, and the public CreateSessionOptions JSDoc now names that supported role. The type-equivalent persistence catalog still described seeds as replay/fork-only, so doc-sync correctly rejected the mismatch.
Align the explanatory paragraph and exact type-equivalent block in both languages, then re-record the bilingual pair. This keeps the public catalog from understating the constructor seam that makes the simplification possible.
The implementation no longer stores inherited policy in SessionHeader or resolves a second baseline chain, but the feature, sandbox, and approval notes still described that machinery. Keeping those claims would make the smaller design look incomplete and invite reintroduction of the generic persistence surface.
Rewrite the owning feature note around the actual delegation snapshot: source-tagged policy events follow the optional fork prefix, ordinary last-event-wins folds establish precedence, and persistence captures the constructor seed with the first materialized batch. Condense the alternatives and consequences to the decisions and coverage that remain load-bearing.
Align the sandbox and approval notes plus the subagent-inprocess consumer README with that contract. Update the four Chinese counterparts minimally and re-record each pairing hash so both languages describe the same shipped mechanism.
The plan unit's same-reference gate for a repeated identical /plan selection
(the one uncovered branch in plan-mode/index.ts) gains an explicit case, and
ui-plan's empty node-half apply is exercised the way sibling surface plugins
do (the ui-conversation no-op precedent). Both files read 100% across all
four axes under the CI coverage lane's per-file thresholds.
Regenerate the cordis/config/persistence catalogs and the module graph for
the ui-plan package and the plan projection unit; add the ui-plan Chinese
README and the Model Experience indirect sentence (allowlisted: the control
dispatches /plan lines, dsh-plan-mode owns the model surface); carry the
QuestionComposer Markdown/scroll improvements into the Chinese ui-question
README; re-record the three touched translation pairs.
goal (GoalService + the 'goal' projection unit), goal-session (automatic
continuation), command-goal (/goal — lands in the materialized effective
catalog and the slash menu with zero client changes), and ui-goal (the
GoalBar dock surface). apps/cli deps updated accordingly.
The simplification deletes sandbox_mode and approval_policy from the parent branch's SQLite layouts. Restoring master's older version numbers would violate the monotonic schema contract and could make a database created by the parent look current under a different layout.
Advance durable session persistence from schema 11 to 12 and the disposable session-query index from 6 to 7. The former rejects the incompatible parent layout; the latter resets its derived tables through the existing version-mismatch path.
JSONL shares SESSION_FORMAT_VERSION 0 during pre-release, so explicitly reject the retired sandboxMode and approvalPolicy header fields instead of silently dropping the only inherited policy facts from a parent-produced child log. New logs carry those facts as ordinary seeded events.
Focused JSONL, SQLite persistence, and SQLite query suites cover all affected source lines and branches.
New client plugin package. The GoalBar component migrates verbatim from the
original PR (phase labels, inline edit form, resume-when-paused, pending
lockout, inline errors); its data path is rebuilt for the projection model:
- GoalDock adapter reads useProjection('goal') from the standard kit — no
controller, no store, no refresh chain, no event listener (the original
PR's Session goal fields, write-revision fence, and coalesced refetch all
dissolve into the value store's seq rule).
- The inject face carries only the three mutation verbs; each reads the CAS
ref from the session's current projected value at call time and maps the
settled RPC result inline (callbacks from inject, live state from
useProjection).
- Seats at conversation.input.dock order 1 (the slot contract names GoalBar
as a resident of this strip), below TodoPanel/QueueDock, tucked against
the composer; hero phase renders nothing for free.
- IconSparkle16 is package-local (sole consumer) — ui-primitives keeps only
the shared action icons.
- goalbar.spec migrates with GoalSnapshot props (activation is process-local
and absent from the projection; the strip renders durable phase only).
The ACP fixture configured read-only as the deployment default for both parent and child. Its delegated write therefore remained denied even with inheritance disabled, so the scenario could not fail on the regression it claimed to protect.
Delete the overlay, scenario registration, sessions, prompt, and 473-line tool-schema sidecar. The Loader-booted headless snapshot remains the real composition guard: only its parent carries read-only while the deployment default is workspace-write, so removing inheritance makes the child write reach disk and fails the test.
Keeping one discriminating snapshot avoids 662 lines of duplicated fixture data and makes the review evidence correspond to the actual security boundary.
dsh-goal/types becomes the client-safe pure outlet (tool-todo dual-outlet
shape): GoalId/GoalRef/GoalPhase/GoalBlockReason/GoalSnapshot, the new
GoalProjection payload, and the SessionProjectionMap 'goal' key merge — zero
host imports. Host-coupled vocabulary (GoalView/activation, change metas,
message source, folds, GoalError codes, the scoped goal/changed event) moves
to src/domain.ts, re-exported from the package root. ./client re-exports the
outlet for client aggregates.
GoalService registers the projection unit under ctx.inject(['sessionProjections']):
applyGoalProjection is a projection-grade last-wins fold — plain-JSON state,
same-reference return on non-goal or malformed events (a throwing apply
would tear down the registry drive; strict validation stays with the write
side and foldGoal). Activation is process-local and deliberately absent from
the projection value.
The parent implementation introduced sandboxMode and approvalPolicy as generic SessionHeader fields, then propagated those fields through both persistence backends, session-query indexes, collision checks, policy-specific seed-boundary folds, catalogs, and a broad test matrix. That storage plane is unnecessary: Session already accepts a validated constructor seed, and persistence captures that seed when the session is announced before committing its first batch.
Capture each parent override synchronously at delegation, append source-tagged sandbox/mode and approval/policy records after the optional fork prefix, and create the child with that combined seed. Keeping header.seedLength at the original fork-prefix length preserves lineage while ordinary last-event-wins folds make the inherited records outrank stale parent history and remain subordinate to later child switches. Unswitched parents still stamp nothing, so children continue to follow deployment defaults.
Remove the generic header fields and every persistence/query/schema branch built around them. Collapse the inheritance suite from ten leaking scenarios to four owned-context cases covering real filesystem confinement, stale fork precedence, delegation-time capture, and the no-override path. The assembled headless snapshot now asserts the persisted inheritance event directly.
This keeps the security behavior while restoring policy ownership to the existing event log and deleting the speculative durability machinery that the original tests did not exercise.
Retarget the feature branch to the current master tip without rewriting its existing review history. Keeping this as a dedicated merge checkpoint makes the later simplification diff attributable to the stacked child rather than mixing base movement with design changes.
Resolve the identified-message API drift in the feature tests by constructing complete user messages, reading the nested tool-result message shape, and adapting the prompt-submit listener signature. Preserve both sides of the user-approval conflict: master’s createUserMessage wrapper and the feature’s inherited-policy attribution.
Regenerate the Cordis and persistence catalogs, re-record the session README pair, and refresh the affected ACP/headless fixtures so derived artifacts describe the merged source rather than either parent in isolation.
Validated with the focused policy/session/persistence/query suites (430 tests), focused ACP/headless snapshots (3 tests), build, doc-sync (25 gates), lint, hygiene, and git diff checks.
Six mutation RPCs (create/edit/pause/resume/complete/clear) move into
dsh-host-apiproxy (the PR's host/runtime carrier is gone): goalService()
resolves ctx.get('goals') with a loud absence error, mutateGoal() resolves
the session's agent (agentFor, the command.* implicit-resume precedent) and
acknowledges with the new CAS ref only. GoalError codes ride err.details.
goal.get and the wire GoalView/goalViewSchema are gone: the read side is the
'goal' session projection (whole values on the history tail page and
session/projection frames), so responses never feed client state — the rule
whose absence forced the original PR's write-revision fences.
The fixture mirrors the host's plan unit: a double-event fold over
command/run (name plan) and plan/mode serves the {active, pending} value in
the projections baseline and advances it with session/projection frames;
/plan joins the command catalog with the host handler's wording; the prompt
path commits an outstanding selection as plan/mode inside the opened turn
(the agent/step boundary parallel). Baseline expectations in the fixture
specs gain the always-present plan key.
Rewrite ui-plan as a pure browser surface plugin. The control occupies the
composer's named plan seat (declared empty by ui-conversation); reads render
the host-computed plan projection through the standard-kit useProjection
(absent key = capability absence, hides the control), writes execute /plan
or /plan off through command.execute. The node half becomes the empty
roster apply: plan behavior (command, policy, projection unit) is owned by
dsh-plan-mode, already composed on the web roster with its policy in
cordis.yml. The superseded RPC-backed setPlanMode face, the WEB_PLAN_SECTION
duplicate, and the node-plugin spec are removed; the roster row moves from
the retired CLIENT_PACKAGES table to the cordis.yml dshClient roster.
Conflict rulings follow the projection-reattach plan:
- host/runtime package (deleted on master): take master; the PR's boot
composition moves to the cordis.yml roster and its goals handlers will be
re-landed in dsh-host-apiproxy; the session.prompt slash interception and
its spec are dropped entirely (superseded by command.execute + command/run
logging).
- client core (rewritten on master): take master; the PR's Session goal
fields/methods, ConversationSnapshot.goal, goalActions injection, and the
hard-mounted GoalBar are all superseded by the 'goal' session projection
(useProjection) and will return as the ui-goal plugin.
- wire contract: union of master's workspace/command/skill domains and the
PR's goal domain, minus goal.get (the read side is the projection block +
session/projection frames; six mutation RPCs stay).
- GoalBar component and spec leave ui-conversation (they re-land in the new
ui-goal package); IconSparkle16 stays in ui-conversation chat.
- The web-slash-command-dispatch note documents the dropped interception and
is removed; the goal-bar note will be rewritten for the projection model.
- pnpm-lock.yaml taken from master (reinstall recomputes).
imccyu
Tianyi Cui
_Kerman