- `SessionSummary.updatedAt`'s wire doc still said "Persisted file mtime",
which stopped being true for attached sessions.
- The core invariant let `session/inherited` fall through the merge-extensible
default. It is core-owned, so it gets an explicit case; an unbalanced seed
legally places it inside an open turn, which the relation permits.
- The Agent Note claimed the boundary reaches disk via `live.pending`/
`scheduleDrain`. Verified false: the constructor append precedes `enter()`,
so it never publishes on `session/event` and rides the creation seed instead.
Attaching is therefore a write where none happened before — recorded, since
only `load()` stays a pure read.
- The deferred-index proposal asserted this change documented the cold-mtime
skew on `dsh-host-apiproxy`. It did not; the README entry now exists.
- `firstLiveSeq`'s firehose gap runs through its own seq, not below it.
- The boundary is not always at `firstLiveSeq` (the idempotence guard), so
consumers scan for the last one.
- `lastActivityTime` excludes by type, so a pickup time still leaks onto a
synthetic closer when a boundary ends an open turn. Documented.
- Pin the fork claim end-to-end: a child inherits a still-running parent's
open bracket below its own boundary, while the parent has none. Fails if the
write moves back to the load path.
- Fix the telemetry title that contradicted its own assertions.
The `/status` call site cannot be pinned the way the other two are: the
command appends its own `command/run` before rendering, so the boundary is
never the log tail there. Its fixture now at least renders over a
boundary-bearing log.
A plugin owning a standalone open/close bracket cannot tell a dead marker
from a live one: an unmatched `compact/start` reads identically whether the
previous writer died mid-compaction or a compaction is running now.
`Session.firstLiveSeq` already holds that answer exactly, but only in memory.
Append the log-only `session/inherited` event at that seq from the seeded
constructor — the single waist all six seeded-start paths pass through
(resume, configured startup on a persisted id, `sessions.fork()`, a subagent
fork child, `adopt()`'s live prefix, and a bare seeded `create`). Read it
through the new `isInheritedSeq(events, seq)`.
The constructor placement means persistence needs no changes: the marker is
already in `events` when a backend captures the creation seed, so it rides
the ordinary seed path with no load-time write. It also covers fork, where
the inherited bracket's owner may still be running — the case a
persistence-layer boundary could not reach.
Activity ordering excludes the boundary through `lastActivityTime()`, since
lazy resume makes browsing a pickup and the three call sites would otherwise
float every opened session to the top of a picker or list.
Conflicts, all in files this branch and master both touched:
- `chat/helpers.ts` — kept both sides. Master replaced the inline env
filter in `gitBranch` with `scrubbedParentEnv()`; this branch added the
surface-marker and compaction-source imports.
- `docs/module-graph.md` — regenerated. Both sides added a `tui` edge
(master `subprocess`, this branch `compact`); the generated row now
carries both.
- Three `.i18n.yaml` pairing records — re-recorded from the merged files.
Blob hashes cannot be hand-merged, and both sides' prose survives on
each side of every pair.
`docs/cordis-catalog/services.md` also regenerated for shifted source
lines and master's new `sessionTitle.rename` entry.
Two comment-only corrections from the final review round.
The `isCompactCheckpoint` redundancy note appealed to the mandatory-marker
invariant to explain something the enclosing branch now states outright:
after e029ffb88 both call sites are literally inside an
`isReplacementSurfaceEvent` branch, so the appeal became retained
reasoning. Say the call sites test it directly.
`appendPreCompactionLog` implied its tool-result content is what survives
compaction, but `bash`'s presenter is static, so the string never reaches
a fixture — the fixtures pin that the shadowed step's card survives.
Neutral text plus a note on where the card body comes from, so a later
reader does not "fix" a fixture to make the sentence true. Verified by the
absence of fixture drift from changing the string.
The replay loop spelled the classification as
`isSurfaceEligibleType(event.type) && !isAppendSurfaceEvent(event)` while
the live listener used `isReplacementSurfaceEvent(event)`. Under the
mandatory-marker invariant these select the same set: the only divergence
is a surface-eligible event carrying no marker, which no active Session
can hold — `Session.append` and the seed construction loop both reject it
through the same `planSurfaceEvent`.
Using the same predicate on both paths makes "both paths classify a
surface event by the same marker" structural rather than argued, and
retires the TUI's last `isSurfaceEligibleType` use.
No behavior change: the TUI suite and all 113 snapshot fixtures pass
unchanged.
Review follow-ups on b9b2e593f, all documentation precision.
The redundancy note on `isCompactCheckpoint` leaned on a reading its call
site does not state: `index.ts` reaches it for surface-eligible non-append
events, which is the same set as replacements only because the marker is
mandatory. Say that instead.
The Agent Note now owns three facts it was leaving to a future reader.
`rebuildTranscript` materializes a component per append-origin event and
runs on mount, color-scheme change, and every reasoning toggle — work
compaction used to bound for exactly the long sessions it serves, so the
cost now tracks session length rather than the surface. `Consequences`
names `surface-replayed-compaction` as the durable evidence for the
live/replay equivalence claim, so the two fixtures that must move together
are findable from the Note rather than the PR thread. `Deferred` records
that a page can now carry a checkpoint whose `surfaceOp.start` fell out of
the window: pagination no longer cuts on the checkpoint's provenance
group, `FoldAdapter` pads with a non-surface sentinel, and `nodes()`
degrades to `degradedSeqs()` — which is already close to the transcript
projection A2 should build deliberately.
Also corrects the definite-assignment comment in the snapshot scenario:
the assertion rests on the awaited setup invoking `beforeMount`, not on
that call being synchronous.
Review follow-ups on the append-origin transcript projection.
The live/replay equivalence claim was stated unconditionally but does not
cover `tool/call`: only replay re-derives call pairing, because a call
event carries no `surfaceOp` of its own and inherits transcript
membership from the `assistant/message` that advertised it — which the
live listener has necessarily just rendered. Narrow the claim in the TUI
README and Agent Note, and record at `rebuildTranscript` why the filter
is replay-only rather than a missing live branch.
Add `surface-replayed-compaction`: the three existing fixtures all come
from the live path, leaving the resume case the bug report leads with
pinned only by a unit test. The new checkpoint mounts with the
replacement already stored and records byte-identical to
`surface-after-compaction-wide`, so the two fixtures now pin the
equivalence they assert. The shared fixture appends move into
`appendPreCompactionLog` / `appendCompactionCheckpoint`.
`MESSAGE_TYPES` is not "human message event types" — it includes
`assistant/message`. Say what the code distinguishes (append-origin
conversation messages vs. model-only replacement copies) at the const,
the `paginate` and `session.history` JSDoc, the apiproxy README, and the
Agent Note.
Also: spell the replace shape as `Extract<SurfaceOp, { op: 'replace' }>`
for symmetry with the module's two other uses; document why
`isCompactCheckpoint` keeps a replacement check that is redundant at both
call sites; say that Ctrl+R toggles reasoning, which rebuilds the
transcript; and qualify "the sole source of derived history" as derived
*model* history now that the transcript is the other projection.
The terminal and history pagination both treated the model-visible surface as
the human transcript. A landed compaction replacement therefore erased the
conversation it summarized — messages the reader had already seen — and a
model-only replacement copy consumed a page's `maxMessages` quota, which could
also split a compaction's provenance from the replacement citing it.
`dsh-session` now exports the marker split `isAppendSurfaceEvent` /
`isReplacementSurfaceEvent`. The terminal replays append-origin surface events,
keeps a shadowed step's tool cards paired through its append-origin assistant
message, and renders one dim marker where a compaction landed; the checkpoint is
recognized through the compaction seam's `isCompactCheckpointSource` contract,
not the shape of the replacement. `session.history` counts only append-origin
human messages. Everything model-facing keeps reading `session.surface`.
Three ui-conversation spec conflicts resolve to master's SlotTestRuntime
rewrites. Adaptation to the new outward session face: ISession gains the
command verb (the composer chip and the /permission picker submit through
it), FixtureSession grows the matching fail-loud stub plus the
waitingApproval summary default, and the picker reads the projection
through projections.faceOf (the ProjectionsFace shape) instead of the
retired store getter.
Two real branches gain assertions (effectivePermissionPreset's backward
scan over non-preset events; the popup options() throw when the projection
vanished between availability and open — a sync throw, not a rejection).
The empty ui-permission node half joins the ui-model entry on the
client-lane coverage debt list (same pure-UI plugin shape, same TODO).
gen-cordis-catalog/api, config/persistence catalogs, module graph, and doc
graphs pick up the ui-permission package, the permissions projection key,
and the /permission command; KnobState and PermissionSelect join the
type-link exemptions (owned by the permission package's own docs), and
ui-permission joins the sentence Model Experience allowlist (indirect via
the host command). The ui-conversation and dsh-permission READMEs gain
their zh halves for the approval/chip and projection/command paragraphs;
all three touched pairs re-record.
Hypatia May
imccyu
Yichen Jiang
kingwl
Tianyi Cui
j-xiang
Turtle
ZiyaZhang