Comparing a feedback-time PR commit directly with the landing merge lets unrelated target-branch changes satisfy a review comment and creates false adoption evidence.
Define feedback-time and final PR-specific patch snapshots, fail closed when the landing shape cannot be reconstructed, and require a target-only negative control before implementation.
A saved complete-file candidate could overwrite newer skill guidance, while a provider-wide outage was indistinguishable from a healthy no-op run. Record the source blob and provenance, reject drift during promotion, and make total adapter failure visible.
Align cadence and feedback acquisition with the evidence contract, and narrow the borrowed-state and negative-control checks so they do not contradict the package and testing standards.
A private out-of-repo maintainer tool turns adopted human review feedback
into candidate skill updates. Only the resulting SKILL.md diff enters this
repository through normal PR review; the tool source, adapter binaries,
provider credentials, and scheduler stay on the maintainer's machine to
keep this repository focused on shipped product code. Kept in proposed/
until end-to-end verification against master lands a candidate PR; the
acceptance criteria list the exact observations that unlock promotion.
Define the in-file RFC contract in docs/rfc/README.md § The file format:
the header block (`# RFC: <title>` plus a dateless Status enum
cross-checked against the lifecycle folder), the per-lifecycle body
skeleton (a Problem opener everywhere; Proposal/Alternatives considered/
Acceptance criteria/Risks in proposed/; present-tense Decision/
Consequences with proposal-era headings banned in implemented/; the
frozen proposal shape in rejected/), and a mandatory Alternatives
considered section with a date-fenced grandfather comment for pre-format
RFCs whose alternatives are not reconstructible from the record.
Enforce it with a new doc-sync gate, scripts/verify-rfc-format.ts, and
normalize all 112 RFCs to it: ~15 Status-line spellings collapse to the
enum, 29 Context openers become Problem, the 39 legacy-format XXX debt
markers are resolved and banned from reappearing, proposal-era sections
in implemented RFCs are rewritten to shipped reality (including the
web/fs/subagent seam RFCs' migration plans and test checklists, closing
the doc-tiers deferred-work item on the web seam), every RFC gains an
Alternatives considered section or the grandfather comment, and the
bilingual pair is re-mirrored and re-recorded.
Move the generated index tables out of README.md into a fully generated
docs/rfc/INDEX.md — gen-rfc-index now writes the whole file, and
verify-rfc-classification checks its freshness and rejects index-shaped
rows in the curated README — which makes room for the format contract to
live in the README front door instead of a separate FORMAT.md.
The decision record, and the first RFC written in the new format, is
docs/rfc/implemented/process/2026-07-05-uniform-rfc-format.md.
docs/rfc/README.md's per-lifecycle tables are now generated between
gen-rfc-index marker comments from each RFC's path (lifecycle/class),
H1 title (optional 'RFC: ' prefix stripped), and filename date, sorted
by date then filename — the one docs region every proposal wave edits
and every concurrent branch conflicts on becomes derived state.
scripts/rfc-index.ts owns the shared walker (closed lifecycle/class
sets, structure rules, parseable-H1 requirement) and the renderer;
gen-rfc-index.ts is the writer CLI; verify-rfc-classification.ts keeps
the structure check and asserts the committed regions byte-match a
fresh render (freshness subsumes the index-completeness check, since a
generated-from-disk table is definitionally complete and correctly
headed). A malformed H1 is a hard error in both directions, so the H1
is now load-bearing as the title source — the one nonconforming H1
(a status suffix duplicating the path) is normalized.
Implements docs/rfc/implemented/process/2026-07-04-generate-rfc-index-tables.md
(moved from proposed/ and amended to the shipped mechanics); the
classification RFC's verify-only stance carries the supersession
cross-link per implemented/AGENTS.md.
Deduplicate the parallel sweep from codex/exhaustive-simplification-rfcs
(merged in the parent commit) against the twelve RFCs already here, on
the merits per item:
Ported (rewritten to this set's evidence standard):
- fold-stdio-ui-helper — verified: dsh-stdio-agent is the only runtime
importer; the fold resolves the documented product-app-depends-on-
support-package tension. The false acp-agent analogy is replaced with
the real distinction (protocol product surface vs one app's front-door
scaffolding).
- generate-rfc-index-tables — verified: the classification RFC records
rejecting generation; the index tables are the repo's only
systematically conflicting docs region. Process framing made timeless.
Consolidated into existing owners:
- web searchStatus()/fetchStatus()/WebCapabilityStatus (verified: zero
production callers; the tool-web README and architecture.md claims are
drift) → drop-web-providers-change-event, renamed
drop-unconsumed-web-observation-surface.
- hook/result.durationMs (unread, nondeterministic, normalizer-scrubbed)
and the double-defaulted defaultTimeoutMs knob →
tighten-hook-protocol-contract.
- the exercised-but-unadvertised exec.arguments mutation path (a
tool-bash integration shim rewrites through it) → a sanction-or-seal
note in the pre-tool-input-rewrite proposal.
- the dormant-guard critique of subagent depth machinery → recorded in
prune-unimplemented-subagent-vocabulary as the considered-and-rejected
alternative, with the keep sharpened (uncapped-today acknowledged;
wiring the cap is the completion, not deletion). getProvider()/list()
and lastAssistantMessage recorded as examined-and-kept (bash-revert
precedent; observe-enrich recorded keep).
Not ported (with reasons):
- tools/change + system-prompt/change removal — recorded keeps in the
adapter-change RFC, unengaged by the sweep; no new facts.
- LlmService.models() — flagged by both surveys, but two lines with a
plausible consumer: TODO-or-drive-by territory per the RFC bar, not
a proposal.
- SchemaProp.default RFC — already XXX(unused-default)-tagged; the RFC
bar excludes TODO-tracked provisional cleanups.
- PreToolDecision 'ask' removal — FIXME(permissions)-anchored deferral
with the permission system as its named consumer.
- Codex bridge Config.model, merged systemMessages — wire-faithful
tested surface / README-documented deferral.
Their in-code TODO notes (acp-test-harness, hook-snapshot-noise,
catalog-type-links) and the stale hook-prompt-block name fixes ride the
merge unchanged.
The branch now bases on the hooks stack (PR #138's head), so every
'in-flight' reference to stack content became a current-state fact.
Audited all nine RFCs + three supplements claim-by-claim against the
merged tree (none invalidated; several strengthened):
- prune-dead-core-spine-surface: describe the landed tools/pre-execute →
dispatch → tools/post-execute pipeline — listeners return Decisions,
the registry builds every result and snapshots it to protect callId,
and a second (mutation-guard) test pins the field; drop the resolved
wait-for-interception hedge; scope the additionalContext ferry out.
- prune-producerless-vocabulary-variants: the ui-stdio fixture migrated
off the continuation trigger (llm-replay is the sole writer now); the
stack's own additions (rejected, prompt/blocked, hook/invoked+result)
all arrived with producers — the admission policy demonstrated live.
- prune-unimplemented-subagent-vocabulary: enrichment landed as
lastAssistantMessage only (agentType was dropped in the stack's own
review — the same judgment this RFC extends); the seam RFC now names
tools/pre-execute deny, which exists, sharpening the re-add path.
- drop-inert-request-knobs / drop-image-content-block /
trim-acp-bridge-unreachable-surface: current-state rewordings (shipped
bridges set no request fields; only compact-basic has explicit image
arms; 13 hook goldens also pin agentInfo).
- generic-long-running-tool-runtime census: second production seam
consumer (hook-protocol runHook: resolve+run, stdin/env, foreground
only — background machinery stays single-consumer); scrub-duplication
blast radius.
- discover-package-inventory: identical 54-entry tsconfig reference
sets; the comparesLog scenario knob (fixture-derivable, like recorded).
- unify-agent-and-session-id: third divergence site (in-process subagent
children mint two UUIDs), the hooks bridge id-lookups, and ui-stdio's
labelBySession map as a consumer that deletes under unification.
New RFCs from the post-stack survey:
- remove-agent-steering-mirror: the last mirror-of-durable event; zero
production listeners; both retention RFCs deferred its fate, and the
'no durable twin' rationale is contradicted by the adjacent append.
- tighten-hook-protocol-contract: producer-less 'native' dialect,
parsed-and-discarded suppressOutput, and hook/result semantics
(truncation + decision-string) defined twice in the bridges instead
of the lib that owns the event.
- single-source-acp-replay-config: cordis.yml/cordis.snapshot.yml differ
by exactly one plugin entry, with no gate on the forced symmetry.
Add a README to each group dir (core/llm/bash/session-persistence/ui/
support) stating its role and product-vs-support classification, and
rewrite packages/README.md around the hierarchy (group table, grouped
"what goes where", removed the package-hierarchy FIXME).
Move the package-hierarchy RFC to implemented/architecture/ and rewrite
it to describe what shipped (placement rationale, the paths-wildcard and
publint dedup, the two new guardrail gates). Fold the remaining
tsconfig.build.json references dedup into the discover-package-inventory
proposal and fix its cross-link.
Update AGENTS.md: regrouped repo-layout map, depth-2 globs, the new
verify-package-paths gate in the doc-sync listing, and a note that we
lean toward stricter lint in the agentic-coding era (machine-caught
errors and a consistent foundation outweigh the one-time cost).
Add a second axis to every RFC — its class (feature, bug-fix,
simplification, architecture, process, testing) — encoded in the path
as docs/rfc/{lifecycle}/{class}/file.md. The folder is the label, so
the closed set is enforced by structure rather than a parsed field.
Two new doc-sync gates back it:
- verify-rfc-classification: every RFC sits in a valid class folder and
the README index lists it under the matching lifecycle→class heading.
- verify-doc-refs: every docs/*.md path cited in a packages|examples TS
comment resolves — closes a drift class verify-md-links can't see, and
catches the four comment refs this reorg moved.
The README gains a Classification section explaining the taxonomy and
per-class index sub-sections. A self-referential process RFC records why
the scheme is path-encoded and gated.
Tianyi Cui
NI0317