ds-review-bot delta-round finding, verified: cordis hands the carrier to
listeners as `this`, and the event declarations type it Scoped<Agent> — so
driving the subject through it (this.send(...) in an agent/* listener) is a
SUPPORTED shape. The withProps-based carrier delegated gets with the PROXY
as receiver, so ReactLoopAgent's send/steer/cancel — which read the
native-private #carrier through a getter — threw TypeError when called that
way (private members do not exist on proxy receivers).
scopeTarget now builds its own proxy: overlay props (the composed filter and
the carrier mark) answer from a null-shadowed literal via hasOwn (`in` would
let Object.prototype's toString/constructor shadow the subject's), every
other get delegates with the BASE as receiver (getters see the real object)
and returns functions bound to the base (method calls execute on the real
receiver), sets land on the base. A proxy-invariant guard reports frozen own
function props unchanged (binding them would violate the get invariant).
This kills the class at the seam — any subject with native privates works,
today's agents and whatever carries them next — instead of patching the one
#carrier field.
Pinned both ways: a scope.spec matrix (native-#private method/getter through
the carrier mutates the real object; set delegation; frozen-own-prop
invariant; overlay non-shadowing) and the bot's exact end-to-end scenario
(an agent/session-start listener calling this.send drives a real turn) —
both fail with TypeError against the withProps carrier.
The exact-disposer fix (5fbac8be B1) repaired agents.register but left the
same wrapper (return () => void dispose()) at seven sibling sites:
tools.register, tools.restrict, systemPrompt.section/tools/variable,
agents.setFactory, and subagents.registerProvider. A wrapper makes correct
composite usage unrepresentable — the exact disposer cannot be recovered, so
a generator effect yielding it leaves the inner effect disposing as a
CONCURRENT SIBLING on owner unload, silently reproducing B1's ordering
corruption. The exact disposer serves both usages (composite-nestable AND
fire-and-forget callable); all seven now return it, typed
() => Promise<void> | void, with the convention pinned by a discriminating
test: an async-link composite probe that passes with the exact disposer and
observes the sibling unregistration firing mid-drain with a wrapper.
Re-auditing also surfaced that B1 itself SHIPPED a full-lint failure: it
changed register()'s return type without updating cross-file consumers
(agent.spec.ts dispose() statements, tool-bash's disposer list), which the
staged-scoped pre-commit lint never saw — pnpm run lint was red at HEAD.
Those three sites and this change's own fallout are fixed together: tests
now await disposers (stronger — they observe the full unwind), sync
paths void them, and the two annotation sites carry the honest union type.
agents.register's README line had drifted the same way (B1 updated the
JSDoc, not the README) — all seven README signatures now match; services
catalog regenerated.
The chained-fused-dispatch spelling fix (0dc2fe90) was whack-a-mole: each
unrecognized dispatch spelling silently drops a producer edge from the
generated matrix, and only a human reading the table catches it. Convert the
class to a build failure: the generator now hard-errors when any DECLARED
event ends with zero dispatchers — dead vocabulary or a missed spelling,
both actionable ('teach the scan or add a DYNAMIC_EVENT_DISPATCHERS
override'). Zero LISTENERS stays legal: seven current rows (agent/request,
system-prompt/assemble, tools/change, ...) are ordinary extension points
dispatched for out-of-repo plugins.
The guard caught a real one on its first run: subagent/provider-removed
routes through the same contained events.dispatch as subagent/start|end
(it fires inside the provider registration's disposer), but the
DYNAMIC_EVENT_DISPATCHERS override list never got an entry when that
containment routing was introduced — the committed matrix (on master too)
claimed the event has NO dispatcher while tool-subagent listens for it.
Override added; matrix regenerated with the producer edge restored.
The partial-toolFilter materialization fix (da6c6d58) stopped one field
short: the adjacent agentOptions key in the SAME Config has the same
schemastery trap. An omitted agentOptions materializes {}, which is truthy —
so every yml-configured load put a dishonest agentOptions: {} on every start
request and the presence check in execute() could never be false through
config (only unit tests bypassing schemastery ever exercised that branch).
Harmless downstream today (the driver only spreads it), but the request
shape lied and the check was production-dead.
Same discipline as its toolFilter sibling: the omitted key now defaults to
undefined, the presence check is spelled !== undefined like its neighbors,
and a regression test (fails against the unfixed schema) pins that an
omitted agentOptions stays absent from the request. Swept every other
Config in the repo for the class: no further instances — omitted primitives
inside a materialized object stay ABSENT (verified empirically), so
subagent-mock's capabilities spread is safe, and the remaining object/array
fields all carry explicit defaults or the forced-undefined discipline
already.
Supersedes the single-slot staging the execution-identity fix (06c5f17e)
kept: the one pending slot needed a mismatch-drop branch plus a defensive
coverage-ignored finally to manage orphans, and it carried a latent trap —
under the loop's documented parallel-execution TODO, two in-flight capture
trips would overwrite the slot and BOTH be dropped.
Staging in a WeakMap<ToolExecution, {value}> makes the stale-stage class
structurally impossible instead of managed: an entry orphaned by an outer
short-circuiting listener can never match a different execution's lookup
(whatever call id that execution carries), needs no drop bookkeeping (the
map reclaims it with the execution object), and staging cannot cross-clobber
under parallel execution. Staging is the only layer this future-proofs — a
parallel cut would still owe its own single-accept rule for the captured
value, which is documented rather than claimed. Behavior is pinned by the
existing orphan/call-id-reuse regression tests, which pass unchanged; the
commit listener loses two branches and the v8-ignore.
Re-auditing the review-fix commits surfaced a regression the REPLACE
re-assert (825cbab3) introduced: unconditionally rebuilding both arrays as
filter(...)+append moved structured_output to the END of the model-visible
tool list on every untampered assembly (overriding the registry's
toolOrder/lexicographic contract) and moved the instruction section to the
absolute array end — renderPrompt reads ARRAY order, so any section above
order 190 would render before the trailing instruction, violating the
sections-sorted-ascending contract. The presence-check version it replaced
touched neither array when the entries were intact.
The re-assert keeps its REPLACE content semantics but is now
placement-preserving: the tool is replaced IN PLACE (duplicates collapse,
append only when stripped); the section is re-inserted at its
ascending-order position (the first entry above 190 — exactly where the
registry's stable sort put it, so the untampered path reaches the model
byte-identical). Pinned by two regression tests that fail against the
filter+append form: untampered placement (tool before a lexicographically
later tool, instruction before an order-200 section) and tamper recovery
(stripped section re-enters its band; an added duplicate collapses to one
right-schema entry).
ds-review-bot round-3 finding: agentEvents(ctx, agent).emit(...) has a
call-expression receiver the generator's identifier check missed, silently
dropping agent-loop as agent/session-start's producer. The generator now
recognizes a call receiver whose callee is agentEvents; graph regenerated
with the producer edge restored.
ds-review-bot round-2 findings: (1) dsh-subagent's runtime import of
@deepseek-ai/dsh-scope was undeclared in its manifest and tsconfig
references (the root paths map masked it; the emitted package would import
an undeclared dependency) — wired as peer+dev with the project reference,
module graph regenerated. (2) The structured re-assert only ensured
PRESENCE, so a downstream listener injecting a same-named entry with the
wrong schema kept it model-visible while validateStructuredValue enforced
the real one; it now REPLACES any same-named tool/section with the run's
own. Pinned by a wrong-schema-injection test asserting exactly one entry
carrying the run's schema.
Codex confirmation-round finding: an OUTERMOST prepend pre-execute deny
skips the runtime's own pre-execute clear, and the denied call still
reaches post-execute — so a reused adapter-minted call id could promote an
orphaned stage on the default accept path. The stage is now keyed by the
ToolExecution OBJECT identity, the one token that provably ties a stage to
one pipeline trip: only the execution whose own body staged can commit,
whatever any call id says. The pre-execute clear is gone (one mechanism);
the commit's mismatch drop is now the reachable primary guard. Repro test:
orphaned stage + outer pre-execute deny with the same call id never
promotes; a fresh valid call still captures.
Adversarial-review findings (own reviewer agent), each verified and pinned:
B1: agents.register() returned a wrapper lambda, so the factory composite's
yield could not identity-nest it — on OWNER unload the unregistration (and
agent/disposed) disposed as a concurrent sibling, firing mid-drain while
the final turn was still closing (pre-existing on master; this branch's
docs re-assert the order, so it must be true). register() now returns the
EXACT cordis effect disposer (the Scope.rawDispose move); the composite
nests it and owner unload runs stop/drain -> unregister -> detach -> scope
like every other path. Regression test pins turn-end before disposed
before detach on owner unload.
B2: the structured two-phase commit could promote a stale stage when a
later capture call REUSED the orphaned stage's call id with a body that
never staged (denied downstream, or invalid args throwing pre-stage). The
runtime's pre-execute listener now clears any stale stage unconditionally
when a new capture call enters the pipeline — only a call's own body can
stage for its commit; the call-id mismatch guard becomes a defensive
second layer. Repro test: blocked capture then same-id invalid call.
C1: an explicit empty toolFilter config now fails at plugin LOAD (the
check is self-contained) instead of killing every delegation at child
setup. C2: Scope.dispose/ScopeHost.dispose @returns state the single-shot
repeat-call semantics honestly.
ds-review-bot finding: forcing only the OUTER toolFilter key absent left
the nested arrays materializing — a deny-only config gained allow: [],
which means deny-EVERYTHING. The nested arrays now default to undefined
too; an explicit allow: [] (grant-only children) still survives. Pinned by
a capture-provider regression test.
Cordis effect disposers are single-shot but not await-idempotent: when the
owning fiber's unload invokes the raw wrapper first, a concurrent
handle.dispose() got an immediate undefined and resolved before teardown
finished — violating the driver's stated one-boundary contract (Codex
implementation-review finding). The teardown chain's FIRST-yielded (so
disposed-last) disposer now resolves a shared completion promise; the
handle path awaits it after the wrapper, so tool-finally, parent-teardown,
and owner-unload all observe the same fully-torn-down state. Regression
test: owner unload begins first, concurrent handle.dispose still awaits
unregistration + session detach.
Every subject-extractor row of the invariants carrier table is exercised
with a matching and a foreign-keyed carrier; the HMR re-apply seed path
(sessions of agents that predate the plugin are marked started) is pinned;
the scoped tool-provider disposal, plural restrict() validation, singular
scopeHost absentee, tool-subagent passthrough, stale-stage drop, and
disposing-parent spawn (INACTIVE_EFFECT, no orphan) each gain their test.
Two genuinely defensive branches carry justified v8-ignore markers.
The agent-scope-contexts RFC (implemented) records the decision tree:
the dsh-scope primitive over cordis extend/Context.filter/no-op fibers,
two-level flat scope with shadowing, restriction/grant semantics, the
scoped-dispatch rule with fused helpers, the setup window, and the
alternatives (explicit scope params, isolate, event-filtering-only,
vendored support) with why each lost. CONTEXT.md pins the glossary.
architecture.md gains the Agent Scope section, the dsh-scope spine row,
the scoped turn-flow line, and an extension-table row (ceiling 1640→1790:
the two-layer registration model is a new architectural axis; additions
are condensed to pointers). READMEs of every touched package re-state
their scoped facts; the stale structured-runtime README section is
replaced by the scoped-registration description.
scopeHost(ctx, services) is the sanctioned way to mint scopes in tests: it
names absent services loudly instead of the cryptic cordis without-inject
dead end, and catches the silent-no-op host (cordis resolves a
dependency-pending fiber's await without running the inject callback).
The ACP ToolPresenter resolves presentations through the session agent's
view (tools.get(name, agent)) so a scoped/shadowed tool renders with the
same definition that executed.
verify-scoped-dispatch (doc-sync + pre-push) pins the dev-invariants
carrier table against the declaration JSDoc set: an event enforced but
undocumented, documented but unenforced, or a registry-subject notification
leaking into the table fails the build. subagent/start|end docs gain their
scoped-dispatch sentence (a real gap the gate caught on first run).
Three dev-mode invariants close the leak-by-default regression class at
runtime: (1) every scope-filtered event family must dispatch with a scope
carrier — a bare dispatch throws at the call site naming the carrier rule;
(2) where the subject is recoverable from the arguments (agent/*, the tool
pipeline, prompt assembly) the carrier's key must BE that subject, and an
assembly context must never carry agent without scope (use
assembleContextFor); (3) a turn/start logged before the owning agent's
agent/session-start is the setup-drives teaching error (setup registers the
scoped world, it never drives the agent).
SubagentStartRequest gains persona (capability-gated like toolFilter); the
in-process driver composes the child's scoped world in the factory's setup
window — persona as a scoped shadowing deployment:persona section,
toolFilter as a scoped tools.restrict() (loud unknown-name validation),
outputSchema as the scoped structured runtime. spawn/fork now advertise
every start-time capability; ACP stays all-false. A parent-scope teardown
effect links each child to its parent through the memoized handle, so a
disposed parent reaches its whole subtree even if the delegating tool's
finally never runs; subagent/start|end dispatch in the delegating parent's
scope.
structured.ts loses the placeholder schema, the final-assembly swap/strip,
the refcounted root runtime, and the WeakMap state: each child registers
its OWN capture tool (real schema), instruction section, and enforcement
listeners on child.ctx, riding the child's fiber. The commit listener is
call-keyed (a stale stage from a short-circuited post-execute chain is
dropped, never promoted on a later call), and one scoped prepend re-assert
listener preserves the final-assembly guarantee against a stripping global
listener.
tool-subagent gains persona/toolFilter/maxDepth passthrough config —
deny-listing the delegation tool (or maxDepth) is how a deployment bounds
recursion; the omitted-toolFilter schema key is forced absent (a
materialized {} would mean an empty allow-list, i.e. deny-everything).
The producer/consumer matrix reads dispatch sites statically; the fused
agentEvents dispatcher, the agent's loopCtx handle, the session store's
captured emitCtx, and carrier-first argument lists were invisible to it,
silently dropping agent-loop/session as producers of every scoped event.
The generator now recognizes those spellings; the Agent type-equiv doc
block gains readonly ctx.
Every live agent owns a dsh-scope context (Agent.ctx, key = the agent),
minted inside the loop's composite lifecycle effect: registrations through
it are agent-visible and agent-lifetime, and agent.ctx listeners hear only
that agent's dispatches. The composite yields the scope's raw disposer
first (identity-nested, no un-nested window), then session entry (scoped
enter captures the session carrier), then registration; teardown runs
stop/drain -> unregister -> detach session -> unwind scope, keeping
store/registry rollback synchronous on every failure path.
CreateAgentOptions.setup(agentCtx) runs after the scope is minted and the
agent registered, before agent/session-start and the loop start — the slot
where a creator composes the agent's scoped world (persona sections,
restrict(), scoped tools); a throwing setup unwinds inside the rollback
boundary. Setup registers, it never drives.
agentEvents(ctx, agent) fuses the scope carrier with the injected subject
argument for every agent/* dispatch (the correct dispatch is the shortest
spelling); assembleContextFor(agent) pairs the agent DX field with the
scope layer selector. All loop/agent/registry dispatch sites converted;
agent/* event declarations carry this: Scoped<Agent>; ctx.agent is a safe
root accessor defaulting undefined, shadowed by each agent context.
dsh-tools and dsh-system-prompt gain a per-scope registration layer over
dsh-scope: a registration through a scoped context files into that scope,
shadows a same-named global contribution for that scope (per-agent persona
and tool variants), and unwinds with the scope. tools.restrict() masks the
global surface per scope (snapshot-at-registration, loud unknown-name
validation, intersection composition; scoped grants bypass). One visibility
function feeds schemas/get/execute, so prompt, presentation, and dispatch
can never disagree; out-of-view executes as UNKNOWN_TOOL.
Prompt tool providers now receive the AssembleContext and return
{schemas, knownNames}: toolOrder validates against the pre-restriction name
universe (a typo fails every assembly loudly) while ordering operates on
the post-restriction schemas (a restricted-away tool is a normal absence).
dsh-session captures each session's dispatch carrier at enter() from the
entering context's scope tag, and the new sessions.flush(session) owns the
awaited session/flush dispatch. tools/pre|post-execute and
system-prompt/assemble dispatch with scope carriers keyed by their subject;
session/created|event|flush by the owning session's scope.
createScope(ctx, key) mints a tagged context over a synchronously-usable
no-op-plugin fiber (one fact drives visibility AND lifetime); scopeOf reads
the tag through the prototype chain; scopeTarget(base, key) builds the
scope-filtered dispatch carrier over cordis Context.filter, composing the
base's own filter, branded Scoped<T> and runtime-marked for the dev
invariants. Scope.rawDispose exposes the exact cordis disposer so a
composite effect can nest the scope's teardown at its yield position.
A single stable required check that needs every other job in ci.yml, so
branch protection no longer enumerates matrix leg names that change as
lanes and node versions evolve. if: always() keeps the job running when
a dependency fails (a skipped required check would count as passing);
any non-success result — failure, cancelled, or skipped — fails it.
The seam's structured-clone boundary admits values JSON does not (BigInt,
Map, circulars), while tool/code-dispatch events must be JSON-appendable —
left unhandled, a sub-call could execute and then fail at logging time.
The bridge now JSON-normalizes binding arguments BEFORE dispatch (a value
that does not survive rejects that one call), so the dispatched form and
the logged form are the same JSON value by construction.
A client-callback throw only becomes a JSON-RPC error RESPONSE to the
agent's session/request_permission — runScenario itself kept going, so a
tolerant agent could treat the error as a denial and the scenario would
pass, or worse, record: the impossible click baked into fixture and
golden, green on every replay. The mismatch is now captured as a harness
error while the agent is answered plain cancelled (a well-defined path
it cannot reinterpret), and the step loop rejects the run on it as soon
as the in-flight step settles. The spec asserts the rejection instead of
the agent-side error echo.
Adds the missing core-data-structures coverage the catalog policy
requires for non-spine seam vocabulary: the code-runtime.md sub-page
with drift-checked type-equiv blocks for all six seam types, the core.md
sub-page row, the type-equiv manifest entries, and LINK_MAP entries so
the generated service signature links CodeRunRequest/CodeRunResult;
cordis/config catalogs regenerated.
The package, coverage, and permission scripting all shipped on this
branch, so the RFC moves to implemented/ with the lifecycle rewrite:
Proposal becomes a present-tense Decision, Acceptance criteria and Risks
fold into Testing/Consequences with what actually pinned each one (the
zero-byte extraction parity, the 100% per-file coverage via the fake
bin, the vitest-in-src caveat, the per-suite pin cost).
InputScript gains an optional permissionAnswers queue, consumed FIFO by
the harness's requestPermission handler. Each entry selects by option
KIND (allow_once, reject_once, …): option ids are agent-issued randoms a
committed script cannot know, while kinds are the ACP-stable vocabulary,
so the client maps kind → the offered optionId at answer time. An absent
or exhausted queue answers cancelled — existing scenarios and goldens
are untouched — and a scripted kind the request never offered throws,
surfacing as a JSON-RPC error on the permission request: the scenario
scripted an impossible click.
This is what lets an approval-flow suite (the sandbox composition) drive
allow/reject round-trips deterministically from input.json, per the
shared-acp-snapshot RFC.
A scripted fake ACP agent bin (tests/fixtures/fake-acp-agent.ts) speaks
real newline JSON-RPC through the REAL runScenario spawn path (tsx
loader, temp cwd, env plumbing); every behavior — prompt outcome,
session/new rejection, persisted logs, filesystem noise — comes from a
behavior.json beside the fixture, so specs script whole subprocess runs
from data. harness.spec.ts drives every step op, both expect-error arms,
the permission-stub default, env forwarding, workspace seeding, and the
harvest ordering/noise/fallback branches. suite.spec.ts runs the factory
for real at collection time: a replay suite over committed synthetic
fixtures and a record suite over a temp copy (write-back never touches
the committed tree; ACP_SNAPSHOT_SPEC_BOOTSTRAP=1 re-bootstraps it),
plus direct cases for the exported pure helpers. The suite factory's
pure helpers (childFixturePaths, fixtureContext, normalizedHeaders,
headerDeltaCount) are exported for those direct specs.
Two branches carry justified v8 ignores, both structurally unreachable:
the waiter in-bounds guard (noUncheckedIndexedAccess) and waitForExit's
already-exited race guard (both call sites sit one synchronous frame
after stdin.end()/kill()). The fake bin substitutes the session/new cwd,
not process.cwd(), into scripted logs — the realpath difference
(/private on darwin) is exactly what the real bin's header carries.
packages/support/acp-snapshot/src is at 100% statements, branches,
functions, and lines under the per-file gate.
The snapshot tier's machinery leaves examples/acp-agent/tests for
packages/support/acp-snapshot (@deepseek-ai/dsh-acp-snapshot), where the
coverage gate measures it and a second example can consume it instead of
forking it: harness.ts (runScenario, parameterized by an AgentUnderTest
{binScript, configPath, tsconfigPath} instead of module constants),
normalize.ts (moved verbatim), and suite.ts (defineAcpSnapshotSuite — the
per-scenario golden/log compares, record write-back, per-suite header pin
with its uniformity guard, and the fixture guard block, lifted from
acp.snapshot.ts). The example file collapses to its scenario table plus
one factory call; env reading (DSH_SNAPSHOT) stays at that edge.
The exactly-one-pin meta-test generalizes from the hardcoded text-turn
name to "exactly one per suite" — which scenario pins is the scenario
table's reviewable choice (per-suite pinning per the proposal RFC).
Extraction parity: pnpm run test:snapshot is 36 passed + fs-policy-reject
failing BEFORE AND AFTER (BSD-sed environment failure, reproduced at the
base commit in a clean worktree — the recorded golden's sed -i syntax is
GNU-only), with zero byte changes under examples/acp-agent/tests/snapshots/.
Coverage for the new src files lands in the next commit.
The harness, normalizers, and suite/guard logic live inside
examples/acp-agent/tests, outside the coverage gate and copyable-only
for a second suite. Propose @deepseek-ai/dsh-acp-snapshot under
packages/support: parameterized runScenario, verbatim normalizers, a
defineAcpSnapshotSuite factory with per-suite header pinning, and
scripted permissionAnswers so an approval round-trip is expressible at
the snapshot tier — the sandbox composition is the immediate consumer.
New group packages/code-runtime/ with the interface package
@deepseek-ai/dsh-code-runtime, per the Code Mode RFC: abstract CodeRuntime
service (run() resolves program failures as an error field, rejects only
for seam misuse), the CodeRunRequest/CodeBindingNamespace/CodeRunResult/
CodeLogEntry/CodeRunFailure vocabulary, and readonly language/isolation
backend descriptors. Registered in the tsconfig maps, packages/README,
architecture service map, and the doc-graph service-role classification;
catalogs regenerated.
The RFC's one forward path token to the worker package becomes an npm-name
mention until PR3 creates that directory (verify-package-paths is
drift-scoped: the now-existing group made the token checkable).
docs/architecture.md ceiling 1630 -> 1640: the doc gained a genuinely new
capability-service row; the row itself is already minimal.
Budget expiry terminated the worker but nothing cancelled an in-flight
host-side sub-dispatch, and a late dispatch could append events after
run_code returned. The bridge now owns a run-scoped AbortController
(follows exec.signal; fired on any run settlement), sub-dispatches get
the run signal, and run_code returns only after the dispatch queue
drains — no post-settlement appends, per dispose-to-quiescence.
(A1) Scope the wire-collapse guarantee honestly: systemPrompt.tools() is
a public multi-provider API, so the mode governs the registry's
contribution (the only shipped source); deliberate extra providers own
what they add, and the shipped-configuration invariant is test-pinned.
(A2) Replace pause-on-pending-RPC timeout with two independent budgets:
computeMs metered by worker.performance.eventLoopUtilization() busy time
(unfoolable by an un-awaited decoy dispatch; probe-verified) plus a
never-pausing maxWallMs ceiling.
(A3) Specify sub-call additionalContext as deliberately suppressed in
the MVP (immediate inject would break call/result adjacency; the plural
channel is named follow-up work).
(B) Orphan-process caveat vs bash-local's group kill; null-prototype
binding namespaces (__proto__/constructor names); per-PR doc artifacts
(packages/README row, architecture service map in PR2, config/tool/
persistence catalogs per owning PR); engines range corrected to
^22.19.0 || >=24.0.0.
Research finding: a SessionEventMap member is a log event — JSDoc prose
required, @mode is a hard error there, and docs/persistence-catalog.md
must be regenerated (todo/write is the log-only precedent). PR4's plan
now names both.
Tianyi Cui
Wenlu Wang